Maintaining safe levels of arsenic in Suring’s water could cost anywhere from $20,000 to $1.4 million, the Suring Village Board learned at a special meeting July 19.
Gayle Lindenberg of Robert E. Lee and Associates Inc., a Hobart engineering firm, provided an assessment of the long-term arsenic removal options for Well No. 2, including pros and cons and costs.
She also presented a history of the well project. Four of the six trustees were not serving on the board when the project started in October 2009. At that time, the well was shut down because the arsenic level exceeded Environmental Protection Agency standards. In May 2010, about $1.2 million was spent on improvements intended to provide Suring with a secondary source of water. Suring also has two wells across the river from the village and is required to have Well No. 2 in case the river crossing is compromised.
The project was fraught with problems throughout the years, mostly caused by iron in the water clogging up the system that removes arsenic. The village has used various methods to get the system to work and keep the well running. In April, Suring initiated a pilot program proposed by Robert E. Lee and Associates and Envirogens, the manufacturer of the treatment system.
The cost of the pilot program was approximately $2,000 for supplies. Initial tests results showed the pilot program would be successful in removing iron. Then it was determined the filters would not be reusable, making the program less economical, so the pilot test was terminated.
At the July 19 meeting, Lindenberg defended the system, stating the firm is confident that by aggressively cleaning or replacing the resin in the ion exchange vessels, the present system will work.
“I know we have tweaked and adjusted trying to get the system to work, and it is taking a little longer than we had hoped, but with new resin we would really like to give it another try using adjustments utilized in the last few years,” she said.
“Personally, I don’t think it’s going to work any better than before,” Suring Public Works Director Les Steffeck said.
The cost of the replacement resin is approximately $20,000-$30,000.
“I’d feel better if Envirogens could prove that this would work,” Steffeck said.
The board was hesitant to spend the $20,000.
“It’s a roll of the dice,” village President Jay Tousey said.
”It’s like throwing good money after bad,” village Trustee George Otradovec said.
The board decided to wait until its meeting Aug. 9 to take action.
Other options provided by Robert E. Lee and Associates Inc. included a sand media filtration system, at a cost of $760,000; iron oxidation pretreatment, at a cost of $1.4 million; and a green sand pressure filter, at a cost of $900,000.
Well No. 2 is located south of Suring at 8794 State Highway 32, near the intersection of Highway 32 and County Road M/Z. A new well station was built to house the filtration equipment designed to filter out arsenic and iron.


