Skip to main content

School day change proposal moves ahead

Shawano high school and middle school students would start their day more than an hour later under a proposal headed to the Shawano School Board to allow students more time to sleep in the morning. An ad hoc committee studying school-day schedules recommended the change Wednesday for students at Shawano Community High School and Shawano Community Middle School. The group also is urging slightly earlier start times for elementary school students so that buses can drop off those students first before circling back around for the older students. The School Board will take up the recommendations next month on an issue that has proved to be delicate among parents, and remains controversial with a new parent survey whose results are being called into question. The survey signaled strong parental support for adjusting school start times, but it did not provide survey respondents the option of indicating a preference to maintain the status quo. Parents turned out at Wednesday’s committee meeting and quizzed school officials about how the survey was presented. “You ticked off a lot of people by not giving them a voice,” parent Jeana Winslow said. Some committee members agreed that the survey was organized poorly, partly because parents could not indicate a preference for leaving school schedules unchanged without first choosing one of the options recommending change and then writing their true feelings in the comment section offered later. “That part wasn’t fair,” said committee member Al Heins, who also is a School Board member. The current school schedule has middle and high students starting their day about 7:30 a.m. and elementary students starting their day about 8:15 a.m. Administrators are studying new schedule options amid a growing national debate about whether students, particularly teenagers, are suffering in their education and their health because of school days starting too early, depriving them of adequate sleep. The survey of Shawano parents asked them to rank three new schedule options: moving all start times ahead by 30 to 40 minutes so that high school and middle school would start at 8 a.m and elementary schools start at 8:50 a.m.; flipping start times so that elementary schools start first at 7:45 a.m. and high school and middle school start later at 8:35 a.m.; or creating a single-run bus system that would cost extra money and would allow later start times that have not been worked out yet. With about 1,000 parents responding to the survey, results presented Wednesday show that 521 respondents most favored the first option, followed by 284 people choosing the second option and 195 choosing the third option. Officials called the results suspect, saying they believe many parents checked off the three options in order so they could get to the comments section and write their real preferences there. “They just clicked through,” said Amanda Korth, the district’s communications director, who organized the survey and helped compile the results. With a total of 473 respondents offering written comments at the end of the survey, 248 indicated that their preference was to keep the current school-day schedule unchanged. Parents at Wednesday’s meeting voiced strong feelings on both sides of the issue. Parent Justin Poulos said he supports adjusting the schedules, saying that it represents a relatively simple change that could make students healthier and create a more positive learning environment. “I think we should do it,” he said. Parent Heather Smith, however, questioned the need to shuffle student schedules. Smith said her school day started early in the morning when she was growing up, and she had a very successful academic career. “What we’re doing right now is OK and it’s working,” she said. “I’m proof of it.” Members of the ad hoc committee wrestled with the survey results — which many agreed were questionable — and instead found consensus with an option that was not presented in the survey. Although no vote was taken, the group voiced support for recommending that the School Board flip start times as described in the second survey option, but without requiring elementary students to start their day as early as 7:45 a.m. Under the plan forwarded to the School Board, elementary students would start their day around 8 a.m. and middle and high school students would start around 8:50 a.m. Acknowledging that the changes would require parents to adjust their daily schedules, committee member Matty Mathison urged parents to keep in mind that studies have shown later start times for teenagers are important to their health and academic success. “We didn’t just grab an idea out of the air,” Mathison said. “We want to do what’s best for kids.”