Skip to main content

Court News

Burglary Two women are facing felony burglary charges for allegedly breaking into a residence in Bowler last month. Patricia O. Leonard, 36, of Bowler, and Holly A. Messer, 33, of Birnamwood, are accused of burglarizing a residence on Jan. 28 and arming themselves with a dangerous weapon. The complaint alleges they stole a handgun along with cash, jewelry and liquor. A trail camera set up in the yard of the property took images of the alleged vehicle involved in the break-in. The images were posted on the sheriff’s department Facebook page and resulted in a tip that led to the suspects, according to the criminal complaint. Leonard and Messer could each face a maximum 15 years in prison and $50,000 fine if found guilty of arming themselves with a dangerous weapon during a burglary. They could also face six years in prison and a $10,000 fine if convicted of felony theft. Leonard was scheduled for a preliminary hearing on the charges Thursday. She is being held on a $5,000 cash bond. Messer waived her preliminary hearing in court on Monday. She posted a $2,000 cash bond and is due back for a pre-trial conference Feb. 29. Witness intimidation A Cecil man already charged with several felony counts as a result of an alleged domestic disturbance is now facing additional felony charges of intimidating witnesses in the case to prevent them from giving testimony. Tyler J. Cotter, 22, was charged in November with strangulation and suffocation, false imprisonment and substantial battery for allegedly beating and choking a woman and preventing her from leaving during a domestic disturbance in Shawano. According to a new criminal complaint, he subsequently threatened two witnesses to keep them from testifying about the incident. He was also charged with two counts of felony bail jumping. Cotter could face a maximum 10 years in prison and $25,000 fine on each count of felony intimidation if found guilty. Felony bail jumping carries a maximum six years in prison and $10,000 fine. On the original charges, Cotter could face a maximum six years in prison and a $10,000 fine if convicted of strangulation and false imprisonment, and 3½ years and $10,000 fine for substantial battery. Cotter was bound over for trial after a preliminary hearing on the new charges Friday. He is being held on a $5,000 cash bond and is scheduled for arraignment Monday. In a related case, Bobbi J. Martz, 42, of Cecil, is facing two felony counts of perjury for allegedly making false statements during Cotter’s preliminary hearing in October on the original charges. She could face a maximum six years in prison and $10,000 fine if on each count if convicted. Martz is free on a $7,500 signature bond and is due in court for a preliminary hearing on May 5. Substantial battery A Wittenberg man is facing a felony charge of substantial battery after an alleged domestic abuse incident in the town last month. Justin D. Furtick, 30, is accused of causing substantial bodily harm to a woman during an altercation on Jan. 23, according to the criminal complaint. The woman sustained a broken rib during the incident, the complaint alleges. Furtick could face a maximum 3½ years in prison and a $10,000 fine if convicted. He is also charged with misdemeanor domestic abuse-related disorderly conduct. Furtick was freed Wednesday on a $1,500 signature bond and is due back in court for an adjourned initial appearance on March 21. Felony OWI A Gresham man is due in court for a preliminary hearing next month on a felony charge of fifth offense operating while intoxicated. Dennis E. Hibbard, 61, was pulled over by a state trooper in the town of Hartland on Nov. 13 for having burned out license plate lights, according to the criminal complaint. The complaint alleges Hibbard failed a roadside sobriety test and that marijuana was found in the vehicle. He is also charged with operating a vehicle with a controlled substance in his blood. Both felony charges carry a maximum possible penalty of six years in prison and a $10,000 fine. Hibbard is free on a $5,000 signature bond. His preliminary hearing is scheduled for March 30.