I am presenting an interpretive role-play called “Lucy Loved Lakewood” at 1 p.m. July 22 at the Holt and Balcom Logging Camp Museum in Lakewood. I debuted it at the Oconto County Historical Society’s Beyer Home Annex in April, and it was well-received. The presentation details Lucy Rumsey Holt’s indispensable role in preserving the history of northern Oconto County. I love sharing Northwoods history, and dramatic presentations are the most popular programs at the camp.
My hour as Lucy includes an exhibit of rare photographs of northern Oconto County taken by and of her from 1894 to 1938. The collection depicts the Holt family’s wide circle of family and friends as they enjoyed getaways at Island Lodge, a secluded summer retreat on a large island in Archibald Lake. Built by Holt crews in 1896 and only accessible by boat, the lodge is still used by Holt descendants for summer vacations.
My introduction to the Holt name came in 1993 when I saw it on the property abstract for land we bought on the Townsend Flowage. I didn’t really take notice until my cousin, Lee Stehula, mentioned it one night in 2006. The McCauslin Lions owned the logging camp back then, and as president, Lee was in charge of the site.
He recruited my husband to help with school tours still hosted annually for area fourth graders studying Wisconsin history. Jon agreed and volunteered me, too. Thus began an odyssey that included unexpectedly becoming head contractor and sole fundraiser of a site-saving restoration that took from 2007 to 2013.
As a token of appreciation from the Holt family, I was invited to visit Island Lodge, where I enthusiastically accepted an offer to sit in Lucy’s chair. I am convinced that experience bewitched me. I began researching her life, finding an inspiring story of a woman who was a hundred years ahead of her time. I subsequently made friends with several of Lucy’s descendants who said I knew more about her than they did.
Truth be told, Lucy and I are as different as can be — except for both of us having a lead foot, an abiding affection for white pines and a desire to record history. I was raised on a dairy farm; she was from high society. As a devout Presbyterian, Lucy never smoked, drank, swore, gambled or danced. I admit that I have done all of those things. Yet when I put on my Lucy costume and look in the mirror, I see the faint reflection of a halo over my hat.
I’ve been doing role-plays for a very long time. To become someone else on stage for an hour or so is as enjoyable as shoe shopping or drinking wine with girlfriends. That sort of amazes me, because I was never in dramatic productions when I was in school. In fact, back then I was very self-conscious and uncomfortable in the limelight. Really.
Somewhere in my 30s, I discovered that portraying both real and fictitious people was a great teaching strategy. It was a humbling experience to learn that the kids paid more attention when I was someone else, but I swallowed my pride and went with the flow.
I played Becky Thatcher (Tom Sawyer’s love interest) as a grown woman. I did Catherine Dickens, long-suffering wife of Charles who flaunted his affairs while she dutifully raised their children. I especially loved doing Hatshepsut, an Egyptian pharaoh who brought economic prosperity to her beloved Egypt. She built monuments, temples and pyramids but was basically erased from history by her jealous stepson who forced her to commit suicide, then removed her name from all of her achievements and inserted his instead.
The best role of my life was Cathouse Cate, the madame of the Red Light Saloon. Maybe it was the red dress, the bling, the feather boas, the freedom to be a teeny-weeny bit naughty on stage. Whatever. When I put on that costume, I felt like I was Cate. Why not? I’m convinced that in a previous life, I was a lumberjack’s lady.
Yes, yes, a century ago, Lucy Holt would never associate with the likes of Cate. However, there is an interesting connection. Saving vulnerable young women from being ensnared in the Chicago sex trade was a key mission of the Lake Forest Presbyterian Church that the Rumsey family attended. Lucy obviously condemned the sin and not the sinner, so I think she’d forgive Cate and highly approve of the fact that she does reform in the end.
If I’ve piqued your interest, why not take a drive to Lakewood on July 22 to see “Lucy Loved Lakewood”? Relax in our air-conditioned cookshack and learn about this amazing woman. You will be educated and entertained; I promise.
Role-plays provide chance to be someone else


