They say that those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
I had a sense of deja vu as the Shawano School Board voted July 10 to hire Dorreen Dembski to handle the district’s communications. Among the things listed in the first year of work includes assisting with the development of key messages for the district and writing up to eight press releases related to those messages to pitch to local media, two on-site photography sessions to develop a library of photos and providing assistance to implement print newsletters.
It’s no surprise that the district is wanting someone to bolster its public image at this time, considering it’s looking at finally making the step forward on a capital referendum and possibly an operational referendum. Having someone in the know about those issues who can answer questions from inquiring minds seems — at least on the surface — to be a wise investment.
The contract stipulates that Dembski will be paid $39,785 for about 275 hours of work, equating to about $145 per hour. In the proposal, however, it’s noted that travel costs are not included in the estimate, and that the cost of travel time will be $75 per hour. Also of note, the cost of printing, postage, video production and/or other production costs are extra.
The reason for my deja vu is that there have been two other occasions since I’ve come to town when the school district has taken steps to have someone handle their public relations, and I’m left wondering what will change to make sure this option sticks. There’s no denying that the district’s community image is shaky at best, and that some spin is needed to put the schools back in a favorable image, but I question whether paying someone $145 per hour plus expenses is the solution to the problem.
The first stab at making the district look better came in 2015, when the board approved hiring someone in-house as a communications specialist. That position came with a salary of $34,000 for work during the entire school year. At the time, the argument was the website and social media were not being utilized very well to tell the school district’s “story.” The specialist could translate the buzzwords and acronyms that educators like to use in order to be cute and make the information more digestible.
Unfortunately, a year later, a consultant told the school board that the communications specialist, along with other positions, was dead weight, and the board members should get rid of it. So they did, surmising that existing staff could handle the public relations.
That didn’t work out so well. Need proof? Fast forward to 2020, with a new superintendent and some dark times for the school district as the coronavirus pandemic was hitting its stride.
The first thing the school board did to try and improve its public image was to pay $10,000 annually for three years to Social School 4 EDU to build its “social capital” by taking photos and posts and turning them into something that engaged people on Facebook, Twitter and all the other sites. The three-year period ended this year, and there’s been no scuttlebutt about Social School 4 EDU. Where did they go? Where did the money we paid them go?
That was only one piece of the public relations puzzle in 2020. Then-superintendent Randi Anderson also pushed for a $20,000 raise for the community education director, with the caveat that the director would “take the lead” for marketing and community engagement. That was a 30% pay raise at a time when other administrators were looking at a 2% bump in money.
To summarize, $10,000 for a company to energize the district’s social media plus $20,000 for someone to increase its marketing for a total of $30,000. How did that turn out? Radio silence when parents were asking when virtual learning would end, rudeness from the school board president when parents questioned why they were not informed the masking mandate was over, and don’t get me started about 2022 when the community was broadsided by a potential school closure in less than two months because of a looming $2 million budget deficit.
Of course, it’s not like public relations for a school district is anything new. Menominee Indian School District has contracted for years with a firm that puts out press releases for it and occasionally works with media to finagle stories, and it’s smaller than Shawano’s district. Pulaski Community School District has a communications specialist who works in-house and also works with the high school’s newspaper to provide sunshine on what’s happening with that district. Having public relations for Shawano schools wouldn’t be the worst thing in the world.
Unfortunately, Shawano also has a bad history of moving forward with makeovers of its public image, only to have the machine that generates the image turn out to be an Edsel instead of a Ferrari. The decision has already been made by the school board, but it would behoove district officials to make sure this effort runs like a well-oiled machine and doesn’t end with the engine falling out of it.
Lee Pulaski is the city editor for NEW Media. Readers can contact him at lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com.


