The Wittenberg Village Board reversed course Aug. 7 on its plans to look into and consider a $1.5 million referendum for road rehabilitation on Prouty Street.
With the referendum being the first in the village’s history, village officials were looking into what would be required to get a proposal on the April 2024 ballot that would allow, with voter approval, the complete repaving of Prouty Street with the installation of curbs and gutters. After consulting with Ehlers Public Financial Advisors, based in Waukesha, it was clear that asking voters for borrowing money for the first time would be wasted on a single road rehabilitation.
“I talked to them first, and then they sent this to me, and I don’t understand it,” said Village Clerk Traci Matsche, holding up a memorandum that the company sent her. “I called about getting a simple referendum put together, but they had other ideas and better ideas about how to get the money together. They didn’t think a referendum was the way to go, but that’s not up to them.”
Matsche, who has previously said she has no idea how to put a referendum together, noted that the village has a maximum borrowing capacity of $2 million, something it didn’t have 10 years ago.
Board member David Timm agreed with Ehlers that a referendum would be an inefficient and expensive venture for the village.
“The referendum is going to cause added expenses, and we don’t really have to do that,” Timm said.
Matsche pointed out that there’s another huge expense on the horizon where borrowing might be necessary, and that involves the village’s sewer system.
“We’re going to have to put big bucks into the sewer,” Matsche said. “We’re not going to be able to get a bond if our borrowing power is back at zero, so if we spend a big chunk of what we have on a street … I wanted to remind you and am just telling you that.”
Board President William Switalla pointed out that repaving Prouty Street is not going to be a huge expense. It’s the installation of curbs and gutters that would sock Wittenberg in the wallet.
“Somebody brought up that they’re parking on the sidewalk near the street,” Switalla said. “Do you have any idea how many sidewalks we could replace for what that’s going to cost us to put curb and gutter on a street that’s been like that for 50 years?”
Switalla added that there is one house that is negatively impacted by Prouty Street not having curbs and gutters but he didn’t think the expense from borrowing should be done to benefit a single property.
“Even with that last horrible rain, holy crap, did the water come down. There was a puddle, but that wasn’t from not having curbs and gutters,” Switalla said. “It’s because the sewer system can only take so much. There was a puddle on every corner, and other streets have curb and gutter.”
Switalla noted that there are other things the village could spend the money on besides curbs and gutters, such as the restrooms in Washington Park that have generated complaints from residents.
“Are we going to beat up the people again, not only in taxes but then raise the water bills and the sewer bills again because we have to redo the sewer plant?” Switalla said. “We take care of our streets. Our streets are pretty damn good.”
He added that while Prouty Street is not the best street in the village, it’s not the worst one, either.
Switalla pointed out that referendum talk first emerged when the village was looking at rehabilitating Vinal Street, which would have involved putting in additional infrastructure, something not required for Prouty Street. The only reason that street didn’t go forward for a referendum, he said, was because bids for the work were “outrageous.”
Timm pointed out that the Wisconsin League of Municipalities is offering options for small communities like Wittenberg to take care of its streets.
“There is more money for streets,” Timm said. “That’s something that we can look into.”
Switalla agreed and pointed out that the village has money now that could go toward repaving Prouty Street. It’s only the addition of curbs and gutters that makes the proposal extremely expensive.
“Is curb and gutter important enough to do a referendum?” Switalla said.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


