Little did Mike Nompleggi know that when he decided to pitch for the University of Wisconsin-Whitewater baseball team, he was starting a trend.
A pipeline was opened for Oconto Falls High School pitchers to head to one of the best Division III baseball schools in the country. Two years after Nompleggi committed to Whitewater for the 2013-14 season, Riley Gruetzmacher, a 2015 Oconto Falls graduate, joined the Warhawks’ pitching staff. Evan Sigmund, who received his high school diploma this past spring, is on his way to Whitewater to pitch.
“I just hope to carry on the tradition of moving down to Whitewater,” Sigmund said.
The three former Oconto Falls players will pitch at the same school. At the same time. That never happened in high school since Nompleggi was a senior when Sigmund was a freshman. Gruetzmacher, sandwiched in the middle, was able to play with both Nompleggi and Sigmund.
“I’d be lying if I said that didn’t play a role in my decision,” said Sigmund about having Nompleggi and Gruetzmacher already at Whitewater. “I just knew they had a really good Division III program down there, and I didn’t have interest in leaving the state to play ball.”
Oconto Falls head baseball coach Charlie Rochon had all three players come up through the system and is excited to see them together.
“That really is special because that’s a quality program,” Rochon said. “John Vodenlich runs a nice program down there and they get quality players. … It’s kind of a destination for baseball players right now in the state. So to have three pitchers going there, yeah, that’s pretty neat.”
Sigmund was in contact with both Nompleggi and Gruetzmacher while deciding whether Whitewater was the right fit for him. Since Gruetzmacher and Sigmund are only one year apart, the two are close friends.
“He went down there and made the team his freshman year, which really gave me some confidence that I can do the same thing,” Sigmund said. “That got me a little excited.”
Nompleggi also wanted to give Sigmund as much insight into the Warhawks’ program as possible.
Everything has panned out nicely for Nompleggi at Whitewater. The 6-foot-2, 190-pound right-hander wrapped up his junior season with a 2-3 record, starting six games and had 11 appearances. He had a 3.09 ERA in 58 1/3 innings, allowing 51 hits and striking out 41. He was named first-team all-Wisconsin Interscholastic Athletic Conference. In Nompleggi’s previous two seasons, he appeared in a combined 18 games.
Nompleggi has been fortunate enough to play on two Whitewater teams that have advanced to the Division III baseball national championship. In his freshman season, Nompleggi helped the Warhawks win the national title. He has a coveted championship ring. This past year, Whitewater also advanced to the D-III world series, which is held annually at Fox Cities Stadium in Grand Chute.
“Being able to do it twice in a career is absolutely unbelievable,” Nompleggi said. “Coming from a small town and not getting that whole championship mindset is a totally different experience. I am so grateful for every chance I get to put the cleats on, especially one more time this final season.”
Gruetzmacher closed out his freshman campaign by pitching in 10 games, all out of the bullpen. He didn’t record a decision in 10 innings of work. The 6-foot-5, 235-pound right-hander had an ERA of 3.60 and tallied one save along with nine strikeouts. He also was a member of the team that advanced to the Division III baseball national championship.
Sigmund, who is 6-foot-2, 180 pounds, is coming off a really strong senior season with the Panthers. He was 6-1 with an ERA of just 0.87. He struck out 85 and walked just 10 in 58 innings of work.
Having coached all three players, Rochon knows Whitewater will have three unique pitchers on its roster.
“Each of them has his own strength,” Rochon said. “If I had to grade the three, Mike is probably the hardest worker, Riley probably throws the hardest and Evan is just dominant.”
Rochon is already planning to make a trip or two to watch a couple of Whitewater games next season.
It’s not a guarantee that all three pitchers will make the Whitewater team, but it would be surprising if the guys aren’t on the opening-day roster.
“It all comes to how much they want to work toward their ultimate goal and whether that’s on the field or off the field,” Nompleggi said. “I’m excited to see what all three of us can do. I’m excited to see all three of us succeed on and off the field.”


