Skip to main content

Sidewalk woes mount with easement issues

More headaches emerged for the Wittenberg Village Board regarding a Wisconsin Department of Transportation sidewalk grant as members learned Oct. 17 they might have to hire a real estate consultant and negotiator to work with property owners to acquire right-of-way. The village received a grant in 2022 from the Wisconsin Department of Transportation’s Alternative Transportation Program that will pay for 80% of the cost to install seven new sidewalks, estimated to cost around $920,000. To make this happen, the village would need to get eight temporary limited easements. Mary Jo Miller, with the consulting firm Martenson and Eisele, informed board members she has already reached out to two real estate firms on a DOT-approved list — Moss and Associates in Green Bay and Becher-Hoppe Associates in Wausau. The firms sent back cost estimates that could cost Wittenberg up to $50,000 in 2024 to acquire the temporary limited easements, which total about one-quarter acre. This comes at a time as the village is finalizing its 2024 budget. “The way DOT works is that they require you to hire someone that is on their list of qualified negotiators and acquisition experts,” Miller said. “They have to reach out to the property owners, and then they have a sale study done. When you can verify that each of the acquisitions are worth less than $25,000, which they should be able to, then they put together this nominal waiver form and then the village would approve that.” Among the costs for the village going this route is $5,000 for the acquisition of the rights-of-way, $35,000 for the real estate consultant fees, and $5,500 for Martenson and Eisele to create legal descriptions and exhibits. Miller said the offers to the property owners could range from $100 to $500, which would require village board approval before being finalized. “It’s absolutely ridiculous, in our opinion,” Miller said. “This is the way DOT does it.” An alternative to the easements could be having affected property owners sign construction permits. Going this route, according to Miller, would require notifying the property owners of their right to an appraisal and compensation, which would be at the village’s expense. “What that means is that it’s one form, a standard form, and you approach the property owner and say, ‘We just need an easement from you so that, when we’re done with our construction, we need to be on your property to blend it and restore it, things like that,” Miller said. The right to an appraisal is a federal regulation. Even after the permits are signed, property owners can request an appraisal, according to Miller. They would even have the right to do so in the middle of construction, she said, which could delay the project even further. “They can say, ‘I want an appraisal. Get off my property; I want an appraisal,’” Miller said. “If that happens in the middle of construction or before we’re about to start or something, and it messes up the construction schedule, that’s a risk you would take by going that direction.” Board President William Switalla suggested going with that route immediately, but Miller urged caution and consulting with the village’s attorney before making a final decision. Miller noted that owners could ask for an appraisal even if the village decides to use a real estate company, and the cost would fall to Wittenberg in that scenario. Miller said that the sidewalks themselves would not be on anyone’s property, but the easements are required during the construction process. Originally planned to take place in 2024, the sidewalk installation is now expected to go out for bids in early 2025, with construction taking place that summer. “This whole process (with the easements) will take close to a year, between the time that they start notifying these properties and everything is done and signed and is recorded,” Miller said. “If someone throws a wrench in it, how much will this put you off?” Switalla recommended bringing the property owners together to discuss the issue, but noted some of the property owners have already indicated they do not want the sidewalk in front of their property to begin with. “I’m looking at the list and see that there’s maybe two that are unfavorable,” Switalla said. “I’m thinking if we just have a meeting and bring them all in here, we could explain the process. Together, the smart ones will help the people who don’t understand.” FYI New segments of sidewalk for the village include the following: • North Genesee Street from north of Grand Avenue to East Wood Avenue, east side. • East Grand Avenue from North Meisner Street to South Mission Street, south side. • South Webb Street from School Street to Washington Park, north side. • East Vinal Street from South Mill Street to Pond Park, south side. • Pond Park from South Mill Street to East Vinal Street. • South Ellms Street from north of Walnut Street to Reed Street, east side. • West Reed Street from Homme Home to South Mill Street, south side, and along South Mill Street to Park Pond, west side. lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com