Skip to main content

Quarry neighbors raise a stink

A move to restart a Shawano County quarry and asphalt plant is raising concerns among neighbors and creating a dilemma for local officials who only recently inherited authority to decide the issue. Northeast Asphalt Inc. has petitioned officials in the town of Lessor to renew its permit for an industrial operation that has been dormant near the corner of state Highway 47 and state Highway 156. The asphalt plant, by some accounts, has not been fully operational since state construction crews about five years ago used the asphalt to complete repair work on Highway 47. The move to restart the operation is stirring apprehension particularly for Porter’s Patch, a nearby farm where visitors flock during the summer months to pick strawberries and other fresh fruits and vegetables. Business owner Troy Porter said the asphalt plant creates pollution and odor that make it difficult for his customers to enjoy visiting the farm. “It’s a big mess is what it is,” Porter said. Representatives of Northeast Asphalt could not be reached for comment. Shawano County officials handled regulation of the quarry operation until 2012 when Lessor town leaders created local zoning guidelines that gave them oversight authority for the estimated 150-acre quarry. The town plan commission is scheduled to consider the quarry issue during a meeting that starts at 7 p.m. Thursday at the town hall, W4055 Landstad Road. Commission Chairman Brian Taubel voiced uncertainty about whether a decision will come Thursday, saying he is unsure what sort of complaints the asphalt plant has generated from Porter’s Patch or other neighbors. Taubel said that while he has generally been a supporter of Porter’s Patch in the past, he has received little information about how the tourist attraction is adversely affected by Northeast Asphalt. “They haven’t really made themselves very clear,” Taubel said. “We’re not trying to be difficult, but we need the facts.” Located at W4314 Highway 156, the family-owned Porter’s Patch farm draws about 10,000 visitors annually with its hayrides, variety of pick-your-own crops and other seasonal attractions. The farm covers about 95 acres and has been in the Porter family at its current location for about 100 years. According to town officials, Northeast Asphalt obtained its first county permit in 1986 to begin quarry operations east of Porter’s Patch. That was followed later by a permit to add asphalt production at the site, which allows the company to process excavated rock in a manner that neighbors say creates troublesome debris and odor. Other than during an estimated two-year period when Highway 47 was undergoing repairs, it is unclear how frequently the asphalt plant has been in operation. Terry Moede, the town’s zoning administrator, said he believes Northeast Asphalt generally activates the site on an as-needed basis, when there is a demand for building material in the vicinity. Moede said company officials have not articulated when they might resume operation. “I don’t think there’s anything in the works right now,” he said. Still, the asphalt company has asked town officials to renew the operation’s permit and decide whether to allow it to resume full operation as needed. Acknowledging that Porter’s Patch is not alone in raising objections, Moede said members of the plan commission likely will have to weigh the company’s right to do business with neighbors’ rights to live without disruption. “It will be a balancing act,” he said. The five-member plan commission has the final say on the matter, with no review by the Town Board. Porter said the outcome could affect the continued success of his business. If customers have to endure the smell and mess of a nearby asphalt plant, Porter said, he is afraid some of them might not visit Porter’s Patch. “They come here for a reason; they plan their vacations around it,” he said. “Yeah, it would be detrimental.”