Skip to main content

Noriega-Avila trial experiences delay

The trial of a Pulaski man accused of sexually assaulting his stepdaughter was due to start Aug. 15 but will be delayed indefinitely after his attorney withdrew from the case. Sara Stertz, the attorney representing Pedro Noriega-Avila, requested Aug. 14 to have her client represented by someone else due to her being in the late term of pregnancy. The trial was expected to last four days, and Stertz told the court she believed she could not endure the strenuous pace of a case for that long due to her condition. Noriega-Avila was initially charged in 2016 with one count of sexual assault of a child under age 13, two counts of sexual assault of a child and two counts of incest with a child by stepparent. Court records show that Noriega-Avila appeared for his initial hearing in June of that year, paid a $5,000 cash bond and then did not return for the next hearing. The criminal complaint states that Noriega-Avila allegedly went into his stepdaughter’s room between September 2009 and June 2010 and assaulted her. It goes on to say that additional incidents occurred in 2014 and 2015. Noriega-Avila married the victim’s mother on July 9, 2010. Stertz noted that she and Noriega-Avila did not see eye to eye on the best strategy for handling the case against him, another reason to find another attorney. “I believe it would be in Mr. Noriega-Avila’s interest to proceed to trial with a different attorney whose strategy may align more with his own ideas,” Stertz said. “Due to my pregnancy, I am finding myself very uncomfortable these days. Proceeding with a trial right now on this kind of case, I’m simply not in the best position to represent this client.” Stertz said she did not feel she could provide “adequate or good representation” to Noriega-Avila, which was needed in such a case. “I have spoken with several other attorneys,” she said. “At least one of them is considering taking this case and is balancing whether he can do so as a public defender appointment. If his answer turns out to be no, he has also agreed to help me find a substitute attorney so Mr. Noriega-Avila doesn’t have to wait for very long.” Through a Spanish-speaking interpreter, Noriega-Avila told Shawano-Menominee County Circuit Court Judge William Kussel Jr. that he was agreeable to finding another attorney if Stertz was not able to represent him. District Attorney Gregory Parker also had no problem with the change of attorney. “Obviously, if there’s a breakdown in communications, the state’s not going to object to the request,” Parker said. Kussel granted the request, noting the severity of the case. Noriega-Avila faces a maximum of 40 years in prison and $100,000 fine for each of the incest and the latter two sexual assault counts. For the child sexual assault in 2010, he faces up to 60 years in prison for each count. “This is a serious matter, and the defendant is facing significant time,” Kussel said. “It is important that he has an attorney who can provide the proper representation in this matter.” Noriega-Avila was missing from the court for almost five years until his arrest in Arizona in 2021. Law enforcement responded to a U.S. Border Patrol station on March 13, 2021, regarding the warrant issued by the Shawano-Menominee County Circuit Court for Noriega-Avila, and the defendant was already in custody when officers arrived. Noriega-Avila was brought back to Shawano County in July 2021. Noriega-Avila remains in the Shawano County Jail on a $500,000 cash bond. He has been incarcerated for over two years, mainly because of the difficulty in finding an attorney the first time around. It took until late 2022 before Stertz was found to handle the case. The next hearing will be a status conference at 8:30 a.m. Sept. 7 in Shawano County Courthouse Branch II. lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com