Skip to main content

Noriega-Avila case going to trial this month

The trial of a man accused of raping and committing incest with his former stepdaughter will start Aug. 15 in Branch II of the Shawano County Courthouse, barring any last minute legal deals. Final pre-trial motions were addressed at a hearing Aug. 3, including concerns that Pedro Noriega-Avila’s immigration status might be brought into the case and whether he was fleeing when he went missing for five years. The motions were made at another hearing July 18. Defense attorney Sara Stertz objected to claims that Noriega-Avila fled the jurisdiction when he was initially charged in 2016 with one count of sexual assault of a child under age 13, two counts of sexual assault of a child and two counts of incest with a child by stepparent. Court records show that Noriega-Avila appeared for his initial hearing in June of that year, paid a $5,000 cash bond and then did not return for the next hearing. “It would be unduly prejudicial, especially under the circumstances,” Stertz said. “That jury instruction was drafted more for cases where somebody ran from the scene or were stealing evidence intentionally, something like that. In this case, Mr. Noriega-Avila posted a cash bond, and there’s no evidence that he understood what his bond conditions were, what he intended to do, what he was at liberty. We don’t know he was trying to evade process.” Stertz expressed concern that the instruction would point to guilt without taking into account the other factors of the case. Shawano-Menominee County District Attorney Greg Parker did not see how it could not be construed that Noriega-Avila fled, considering he was missing from the court for almost five years until his arrest in Arizona in 2021. “He posted cash. He was not seen after that until he crossed the border (into Mexico),” Parker said. Parker noted that law enforcement responded to a U.S. Border Patrol station on March 13, 2021, regarding the warrant issued by the Shawano-Menominee County Circuit Court for Noriega-Avila, and the defendant was already in custody when officers arrived. Noriega-Avila was brought back to Shawano County in July 2021. “The jury certainly has the ability to determine whether or not he left because he had sexual assault charges against him or if he went on vacation for a number of years out of the country,” Parker said, noting that the fleeing claims will be part of his opening statement at the trial. Stertz told the court that she feels that bringing up Noriega-Avila’s immigration status is irrelevant to the case and would be prejudicial. Parker pointed out that the immigration status is also irrelevant to him in regards to the facts of the case. “The man took off for the border to avoid prosecution; this is what this is about,” he said. “His immigration status is not part of the discussion.” In another motion, Stertz asked to dismiss the case, and Parker was concerned that if the matter was not settled prior to trial, it could impact whether the trial could proceed to completion. “I’m a little concerned that, if we go forward with the trial, and this motion has been filed, I just don’t want to see any of us go through all of this again,” Parker said. Stertz said that she did further research on the matter and found that the case cannot be dismissed with prejudice because there was no misconduct on the part of the state. She had made the motion because it had been two years since Noriega-Avila was incarcerated at the Shawano County Jail, but that’s because of systemic issues with the court system, like finding legal counsel and, in this case, available Spanish-speaking interpreters to translate the proceedings to the defendant. Those issues cannot be laid at the feet of the district attorney’s office, she said. Stertz noted that she did want to continue pursuing the motion because it would continue to delay proceedings, something she feels would not benefit her client. “I discussed it with my client, and he would rather not wait another year to go to trial, so we will be withdrawing that motion,” Stertz said. Stertz also filed a motion regarding the DA’s plans to call for an expert witness, but Parker explained to the court that, upon further review, an expert witness would not be needed for Noriega-Avila’s case. Noriega-Avila remains in jail on a $500,000 cash bond. lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com