Skip to main content

Appeals court reopens suit by man who fell on ice

An appeals court last week gave an Eland man a second chance to prove a Wittenberg apartment building owner is responsible for the severe shoulder injury he received when falling on ice in the front of the building. The District III Court of Appeals on Feb. 16 overturned a decision by Shawano County Circuit Judge James Habeck, who had dismissed Michael Koch’s negligence lawsuit against the owners and insurers of an apartment building at 108 Vinal Ave. in Wittenberg. “(Habeck) erred by finding the accident occurred on a public sidewalk, and that a genuine issue of material fact exists as to the location of Koch’s accident,” according to the six-page unsigned opinion. Ice and snow had accumulated on a cement pad that extended from the curb on Vinal Street to the entrance of the apartment building where Koch fell on Feb. 14, 2011. Koch, who was uninsured, sustained permanent injuries and has medical bills exceeding $110,000. His doctor also recommends further surgery on the injured shoulder, according to Koch’s attorney, Randy Frokjer. The building’s owners, McClay Enterprises LLC, of Wausau, and their insurer, Little Black Mutual Insurance, had asked Habeck to dismiss Koch’s suit contending that the fall occurred on the public sidewalk, that the owner of property abutting a street is not liable for injuries for not removing snow on a sidewalk, and that Koch’s negligence exceeds any possible negligence of McClay. After a hearing, Habeck granted McClay and Little Black summary judgment and dismissed Koch’s complaint. According the appeals opinion: In the days following his fall, Koch saw the area where he fell was still covered with ice and snow. He told Shawn McClay, a member of the LLC, that he was concerned others may fall and injure themselves. McClay allegedly told Koch that McClay Enterprises was responsible for maintaining the area where the accident occurred, and it had hired a third party to remove the snow. McClay’s insurance adjuster also told Koch the area of the fall was McClay’s responsibility to maintain. The village of Wittenberg wrote McClay on Jan. 6, 2011, that it had received several complaints indicating McClay was in violation of municipal code provisions requiring sidewalks to be cleared of snow and ice. The letter further stated, “Right now, the sidewalk is treacherous.” In his appeals brief, Frokjer wrote that McClay swore at Koch when told about the icy area in front of his building. McClay also allegedly said he encountered other slip-and-fall incidents in the past and they were hard to prove. A month after Koch’s fall, the area had still not been cleared of ice and snow. Little Black’s representative told Koch that McClay was callous toward any effort to address the problem and that essentially McClay Enterprises and Little Black were fully responsible. In the appeals brief for Little Black and McClay Enterprises, attorney Michael Konz wrote that Koch testified that he was walking on the sidewalk when he fell. Koch said he chose the path he did because it had been trampled by other pedestrians indicating, to Konz, that Koch was on the sidewalk. Konz cited prior state Supreme Court decisions that established a statutory duty upon the municipality to clear the public sidewalks of snow and ice. “Any potential cause of action in this case would lay against the Village of Wittenberg for violation of its statutory duty to maintain the public sidewalk,” Konz wrote. Regardless of who is responsible for Koch’s fall, the District III Court said there is no proof of where it occurred. “Quite simply, there is no evidence sufficient to determine, on summary judgment, that Koch fell on a public sidewalk owned by the municipality rather than while walking on that portion of the cement pad located on McClay’s property. The general public can travel over either area,” according to the opinion. A call to Frokjer was not returned by deadline. In a phone interview, Konz said he was surprised by the opinion, adding that he did not think the location of the accident was “a difficult call.” “A sidewalk is a sidewalk and the photos should show that,” he said. While property owners can get ticketed for not removing snow from a sidewalk in time, ultimately a sidewalk is city property. “The liability would be no different than if he was crossing the street in a crosswalk and fell,” Konz said. Koch added Wittenberg as a defendant to the suit after Habeck’s ruling, but the village was not a part of the appeal. Konz said the village will have to defend itself when the suit returns to circuit court.