Shawano School Board members are finding themselves deeply divided over whether to juggle school start times so older students can sleep later in the morning.
Reflecting divisions within the community on an emotional issue, board members struggled for a consensus Monday on whether to accept or reject a plan that would delay high school and middle school by one hour each day while requiring elementary school students to start their day earlier.
An ad-hoc group has urged the schedule adjustment based on research showing that older students need to sleep later in the morning to maintain a healthy lifestyle and do well in school.
With many parents complaining that the change would cause upheaval in their household routines, some School Board members expressed reluctance Monday about going forward with the retooled start time schedule.
Board member Beth McFarlane voiced doubts that, with so many factors affecting academic success, a later start time would turn Shawano high schoolers and middle schoolers into “star students.”
“I worry that some people view this as a magic wand to fix everything,” McFarlane said. “It’s one small piece.”
Others expressed support for the ad-hoc group’s recommendations, arguing that the scientific research offers encouragement that allowing teenagers more sleep time would benefit them in many ways, including physical and mental health.
Citing poor academic performance among many Shawano students, board member Michael Sleeper urged his colleagues to embrace the research that links healthier sleep habits to improved learning, behavior and achievement.
“Change is difficult; we’re all creatures of habit,” Sleeper said. “Sometimes you have to make change for the betterment.”
Meeting as a committee of the whole, the nine-member School Board debated the issue for about two hours Monday. The board is scheduled to revisit the subject and possibly make a decision at the regular board meeting scheduled for April 4.
Any change in school schedules would take effect with the start of the 2016-17 school year.
School administrators are studying new schedule options amid a growing national debate about whether teenagers are suffering in their education and their health because of school days starting too early. The American Academy of Pediatrics last year urged later start times at high schools and middle schools.
To consider the matter locally, school administrators impaneled an ad-hoc group that included health care experts, parents, educators and others.
The current school schedule in Shawano has middle and high students starting their day about 7:30 a.m. and elementary students starting about 8:15 a.m.
The ad-hoc group has recommended flipping the schedule so that elementary students would start their day first, at approximately 8 a.m., followed by middle and high school students starting their day 30 minutes or more after that. The panel did not attempt to propose a specific schedule and instead offered School Board members general direction on the rearranged start times.
In a district survey and public meetings, parents in the school system have split sharply on the issue, with some applauding the proposed change and others saying it would create disruption for families.
School Board members also have wrestled with the cost of school bus service, which could increase dramatically if the district does not stick with its current arrangement of dropping off one group of students and then circling back around for the rest.
Board member Marcia Yeager said she is concerned that the district has not adequately considered how a new start time schedule would impact such secondary issues as extracurricular activities for students.
“We do have to think about those things,” Yeager said. “There’s so many cons to this that we need to look at.”


