Skip to main content

2nd suit accuses police chief of sex discrimination

A Shawano Police Department employee has filed a civil suit in federal court against the city of Shawano over alleged sexual discrimination by Police Chief Mark Kohl and the city’s alleged inaction in responding to the issue. It is the second suit filed alleging sexual discrimination by Kohl in as many months. On Friday, Laura Chartraw alleged Kohl began sexually discriminating against her in February 2015, and when she complained to him and to city officials, Kohl retaliated by creating a hostile work environment. Chartraw’s suit alleges Kohl commented on Chartraw’s appearance, telling her she wore “hooker boots” and remarked about her lack of makeup and her hair style. When Chartraw complained to Kohl, he told her that is the way he talks to his wife and called Chartraw his “work wife,” according to the court filing. Chartaw also alleged Kohl several times made comments to her about police officer NiCole Hoffmann, mentioning Hoffmann’s chest size, weight and eating habits. Chartraw told Kohl that his comments made her uncomfortable, but Kohl continued to make similar comments, she said. Hoffmann filed suit against Kohl in May alleging sex discrimination for bypassing her and hiring a lower-ranked male applicant for a police officer vacancy in July 2014. The city is not named as a defendant in that case. Kohl subsequently hired Hoffmann in January 2015, but her suit seeks damages for loss of past and future income. Chartraw alleged that Kohl’s pattern of sex discrimination includes requiring female employees to tell him when they come or go to lunch. Chartraw is also required to personally greet Kohl, smile more and make eye contact with him when she is around him, according to the suit, which maintains Kohl does not require the same behavior from male employees. When Chartraw told Kohl she does not appreciate the way he treats female employees, Kohl called her “insubordinate” and told her she “can’t handle her job,” despite no documented performance deficiencies, according to the suit. The suit also alleges Kohl created a hostile environment at work by isolating Chartraw physically in her office, excluding her from management meetings and advising other employees not to speak to her. On Nov. 4, 2015, Kohl yelled and belittled Chartraw at a meeting to a point where she feared for her safety and her job, the suit states. Chartraw talked to then-Mayor Lorna Marquardt about Kohl’s harassment, but she took no action and Kohl continued to threaten Chartraw’s job and intimidate her, according to the suit. Chartraw complained to City Administrator Brian Knapp, which resulted in the city hiring an outside attorney to investigate her complaints. The investigation characterized the incidents between Chartraw and Kohl as “communication issues” and not sex/gender-based conduct, and did not analyze any of the incidents as retaliation. The investigation found there was not sufficient evidence of illegal discrimination to pursue further action. The report did not recommend any disciplinary action against Kohl. Kohl was not available for comment Tuesday. Knapp said the city would not comment on any of Hoffmann’s or Chartraw’s allegations since they were matters in pending lawsuits. Knapp also declined to release the report from the investigation of Chartraw’s complaint to city officials. He said it was a privileged attorney work product not subject to disclosure. The suit alleges that the city failed to stop and thus condoned the hostile work environment created by Kohl, and failed to prevent and correct Kohl’s alleged harassment. Chartraw has been employed by the Shawano Police Department since 1998, is the support services manager — a civilian position — and reports directly to Kohl. Chartraw’s attorney, Sandra Graf Radtke, said her client followed proper procedures in reporting Kohl’s alleged discriminatory conduct but the city failed to properly investigate it. “They found no sexual motivation (to Kohl’s conduct), but a hostile work environment doesn’t have to be motivated by sex but sex-based conduct, which we think there was,” Radtke said Tuesday. Kohl’s most egregious incident occurred in the November meeting where many employees witnessed him lunge across the table, which resulted in his being told to undergo anger management training, Radtke said. “It’s really unfortunate that the chief of police can’t conduct himself in a reasonable and professional manner, and that the mayor did nothing to help,” Radtke said. Chartraw “really likes her job and is good at it,” but continues to work in a hostile environment, Radtke said. Chartraw’s suit seeks a court order finding she has been sexually discriminated against and damages for wages she has lost and will lose based on alleged unlawful conduct. She is requesting a jury trial in the case.