Skip to main content

Are you an elephant or a donkey?

I try to avoid political comment in this space because no matter what I might say, I’d probably offend someone, right? And although this year’s presidential race seems to be screaming for comment, I’ve held my pen. I haven’t commented and I won’t. Darn! Instead, I thought it might be fun to look at how the parties represent themselves symbolically. Why would a political entity decide to use a donkey or an elephant to be its emblem? Well, Democrats contend that the donkey is smart and brave, while Republicans say the elephant is strong and dignified. OK, but for most people, the donkey is stereotypically bumbling, slow and stubborn; the elephant — big and clumsy. I would think that being compared to one of these animals would not be exactly flattering. Still, for well over a hundred years, they have been the popular symbols of our two major political parties. So how did the donkey and elephant enter into our political lexicon? Interestingly, they both started out as insults! Insults — in a political campaign? No! You’re kidding! We have to go back to the 1828 presidential campaign to see the first use of the now-famous Democratic donkey. Andrew Jackson’s opponent in the race was the incumbent president, John Quincy Adams. It was a rematch from the 1824 race in which Jackson had won a plurality in the electoral college vote, but the House of Representatives gave the presidency to Adams. The presidential election between Republican (not to be confused with the modern Republican Party, which was formed a few decades later) John Quincy Adams and Democrat Andrew Jackson in 1828 is often regarded as one of the dirtiest campaigns ever run in American politics (and there weren’t even any super-PACs!). Jackson and his supporters called Adams corrupt, spoiled and a “libertine” – someone who lacked moral restraint, usually in reference to sexual matters. Adams’s campaign called Jackson a “jackass” – comparing him to a stubborn, dumb donkey. Jackson considered himself a “populist” and his slogan, “let the people rule,” reinforced this. Republicans claimed that if the people ruled, it would be a bunch of jackasses ruling the country. But Jackson, a savvy politician, was amused by the insult and turned the jackass into a positive symbol. In his campaign addresses, he pointed out the virtues of being a “jackass”: strong-willed, persistent, loyal and able to carry a heavy load. It also symbolized humble origins and simplistic virtues, an “ode to the common man.” This helped Jackson further differentiate himself from the aristocratic Adams. Jackson wanted to be the president of choice for everyday citizens. So he used the donkey on his campaign posters, and Jackson became the first Democratic president. Later, in 1870, Harper’s Weekly cartoonist Thomas Nast used the Democratic donkey in newspaper cartoons and made the symbol famous. The donkey was supposed to represent an anti-Civil War faction. But the public was immediately taken by it, and by 1880 it had already become the unofficial symbol of the party. The elephant first made an appearance during the 1864 presidential election in a pro-Lincoln newspaper, Father Abraham (really just a political propaganda sheet). Father Abraham depicted an elephant carrying a banner and celebrating Union victories in the war. At the time, there was a popular slang phrase “seeing the elephant,” which meant to engage in combat. Coincidentally, and not intentionally, Thomas Nast popularized the Republican elephant. In 1871, in a Nast cartoon in Harper’s Weekly, he warned Republicans that their intra-party fighting could cause them to lose the election. (How familiar does that sound?) In another cartoon that appeared in Harper’s Weekly in 1874, Nast drew a “democratic” donkey clothed in a lion’s skin, scaring away all the animals at the zoo. One of those animals, a wobbly, unbalanced elephant, was labeled “The Republican Vote.” That’s all it took; the pachyderm became associated with the Republican Party. So, thanks to Thomas Nast, by 1880 the donkey and elephant became the accepted symbols used by other political cartoonists and writers for the two political parties, and the association has stuck around since.