A woman charged in the heroin overdose death of her boyfriend will spend eight years in prison, double the length of imprisonment recommended by her attorney and the state.
Oconto County Circuit Court Judge Michael Judge also imposed seven years of extended supervision for Tiffany Gerrits, 25, on Thursday, noting Gerrits needs long-term rehabilitation to address alcohol and drug issues dating back to age 11.
Donald Hudson, 21, died of a drug overdose on Aug. 29, 2014, after injecting heroin Gerrits purchased at a Western Avenue apartment in Green Bay. Gerrits told law enforcement authorities she passed out after using heroin on Aug. 28, 2014, and found an unresponsive Hudson in the bedroom of the Hudsons’ home in Abrams the next morning.
“We have lost a young man forever. Mr. Hudson. What could be worse than that?” Judge said.
“He was the only thing I had,” said Hudson’s mother, Cindy Hudson. “I lost a daughter nine months before that.”
In a plea agreement reached in January, Gerrits pleaded no contest and was found guilty of first-degree reckless homicide. She wiped away tears as the sentence was read.
Judge said heroin is becoming a scourge in Oconto County and promised severe consequences for others who use or deal heroin or cause an overdose.
“Other individuals hopefully will say, ‘I’m not going to get involved in that type of drug activity,’” Judge said.
Judge said he looked for some type of redeeming character of Gerrits, and the first evidence was as a 24-year-old when she took responsibility for her role in the death, cooperated with authorities, issued apologies and expressed remorse. He expressed the hope that she truly wanted to change, despite the dysfunction in her family she experienced.
“It’s up to you. It’s truly up to you if you will be clean and sober once you are released from confinement,” he said.
“I’ll be first to admit a prison term will benefit me, so I can get the help I need,” said Gerrits, who has already spent over a year in jail.
She apologized to Hudson’s family and said she is reminded every day that her actions caused his death.
“I cared about Donnie, and I never intended to hurt him,” she said.
She admitted she needs to learn how to deal with the ups and downs of life without getting high. She said she wanted to be a better person after completing her sentence, “for myself and for Donnie.”
Oconto County District Attorney Ed Burke and Gerrits’ attorney, Gregory Gerbers, in a joint recommendation, called for four years imprisonment and 11 years of extended supervision. Burke said it was the first case prosecuted in Oconto County that involved supplying drugs to another person that resulted in death.
He recommended four years imprisonment in order for Gerrits to receive counseling and be punished, saying she “figuratively loaded the gun” by giving Hudson heroin.
Hudson’s mother, Cindy, haltingly read a statement she had written, pausing at times to compose herself. She described her son as a good-hearted kid, a follower, not a leader, who did whatever he could to help people out and put a smile on their face if they were down.
She admitted he wasn’t an innocent kid but learned from his mistakes. Finding it hard to get a job, he was a caregiver for his grandmother, who suffered from dementia.
Cindy Hudson said she met Gerrits in July 2014, and Gerrits moved into the Hudson home soon afterward. Although they dated only a short time, Cindy Hudson said Gerrits “had such control” over her son.
“Bad news” is how Theresa Benjamin, of Oconto, described Gerrits, in her remarks at the hearing. Donald Hudson was best friends with three of Benjamin’s sons and is pictured in many of their family photos, she said.
“Our family feels like we lost one of our boys,” she said.


