A plan to honor a standout athlete and war hero from Oconto Falls with a monument at Memorial Field is on hold.
Harry Spice, a distant cousin of Roger W. Greetan, began a campaign to raise money for a 20- by 15-foot memorial to Greetan, a four-sport letter-winner at Oconto Falls High School and the only resident of Oconto Falls to be killed while serving his country in the Vietnam War.
Preliminary drawings of the memorial show a flag pole and three stone monuments set side-by-side. The center one showing Greetan’s portrait is flanked by stones showing images of Greetan in a sports setting and a military setting.
Speaking to the Times Herald last week, Spice said he wanted to give Greetan the honor and respect he deserves as a war hero while also recognizing his athletic ability. He heard about plans to renovate Memorial Field and put his plan into action.
“I thought, ‘Perfect time for this,’” he said.
The 50th anniversary of Greetan’s death is July 18, 2017, and Spice was hopeful a monument would be erected by that date and coincide with the first summer of play at the new baseball diamond.
“That would be quite a dedication for the park,” he said.
Spice said he is uncertain of the cost of the memorial, which might be scaled back if funding isn’t available. He shared his plans with Parks and Recreation Director Sheila Manns, who forwarded them to City Administrator Vicki Roberts.
“I was told the project was approved,” Spice said.
The City Council, however, was reluctant to endorse the project right off the bat.
“I personally would like him to come back with some cost estimates, time frame he’s looking at,” Alderman Mathew McDermid said.
Spice said he was provided misleading information from city officials regarding permission to proceed with the memorial.
Alderman Don Osborne said the council has the authority in the decision-making process, not the parks and recreation director. Osborne originally heard Spice’s proposal in February at a meeting of the local Disabled American Veterans and was taken aback because the proposal had not been granted council approval.
“It is our field. The City Council controls it, and we’re going to decide who gets in it and who doesn’t,” he said.
He said a simple flag pole or a plaque wouldn’t be a big deal, but this was a big project that could cost as much as $50,000, an amount that might be hard to raise.
“We need to see the financial statements on this because we don’t want to dig up a piece of ground and let it sit there for years and years,” Osborne said.
Manns said it’s “common sense” to know the cost of the memorial would be covered before it was erected.
Robert said she has been in contact with Manns for several months regarding Spice’s interest in honoring Greetan.
“Then when it got to be the potential size of this, this is the reason we’re sitting here today,” Roberts said.
Alderman Jay Kostreva questioned if the city should “go hog wild with memorials” and instead name a field after Greetan, and Manns said a field could be named in his honor.
McDermid asked if Greetan could be honored at a veterans memorial that the local American Legion and Auxiliary members plan to construct at the corner of Central Avenue and Franklin Street. Manns said the intention is to honor Greetan’s military service and athletic connection to the city, so the park is a fitting site.
A Greetan memorial, with a flag pole and monument, is already in place by the volleyball courts at Memorial Field, but Spice said he hopes to erect a memorial inside the park that draws greater recognition for Greetan.
McDermid, who ran the meeting in the absence of Mayor Brad Rice, brought a terse back-and-forth exchange between Osborne and Manns to an end by saying the council was not ready to act on the memorial. Instead, he said Spice should attend an upcoming meeting and provide information to the council regarding a plan to honor Greetan.
Spice said he will slow down his fundraising efforts until after the plan is approved, but in order to have the memorial in place for the 50th anniversary of Greetan’s death, the monument needs to be ordered in July.


