Photographs of the victim and testimony from the victim’s sister will be admissible in a fatal hit-and-run trial next month, a judge decided last week at a pretrial hearing in Oconto Circuit Court.
Judge Michael Judge on June 21 ruled “the jury has the right to see the impact of the vehicle and the deceased” in the case against Joseph Anderson, 36, of Pulaski. He is charged in the fatal hit-and-run death of George Birr, 51, last December.
Defense attorney Aaron Krzewinski argued pictures of Birr were disturbing and feared they would illicit an emotional response from the jury.
Anderson sat quietly with his head lowered as Judge explained that a photograph of the victim might help the jury discern how large the impact of the vehicle was and if Anderson could have known what he hit.
Early in the morning of Dec. 21, Birr was discovered in a ditch on the north side of County Road S, west of Sobieski, in the town of Little Suamico. According to court documents, law enforcement officers believe he was hit by a vehicle between 8 and 10 the previous night.
After seeking information from the public in December, police received an anonymous call that Anderson was looking for car parts for his white GMC pickup truck, specifically to fix damage to the front passenger side headlight, mirror and fender.
According to court documents, Anderson told investigators he thought he hit a mailbox, a deer or a trashcan.
“I lit a cigarette and all of a sudden I heard a loud bang coming from the right side of the vehicle,” he said when interviewed by law enforcement.
Judge also denied Krzewinski’s request regarding Anderson drinking alcohol prior to the alleged hit-and-run. Krzewinski argued no blood alcohol test was done, making it is impossible to determine whether Anderson was intoxicated.
Judge ruled that witnesses can provide testimony regarding how much Anderson drank, even though an alcohol impairment test wasn’t completed.
Birr was staying with his sister in Sobieski at the time of the incident, and on the morning of Dec. 21, she went to the crime scene. She told police her brother enjoyed late evening walks and did not return the previous night, according to court documents.
Krzewinski filed a motion to prevent Birr’s sister from testifying because she did not witness the incident and did not formally identify Birr’s body.
Assistant District Attorney Robert Mraz argued the sister’s testimony was necessary since it establishes a time line and a pattern of the victim as to why he was walking on the road. Judge ruled in Mraz’s favor.
A jury trial for Anderson is scheduled from July 18-21 in Oconto County Circuit Court. If found guilty, Anderson faces a maximum of 25 years incarceration.


