Shawano School District, like most other districts, is having difficulty finding substitutes whenever a teacher or paraprofessional must be gone for a day, week or even several months.
Currently, the district has an in-house substitute teacher coordinator who makes calls to available substitutes to fill the gaps, but oftentimes, schools must ask regular staff to help during their preparatory periods when there’s not enough subs rising to the call. That has led the district to look at utilizing a service called Teachers on Call, which has access to a broader pool of subs from around northeast Wisconsin and could help relieve the burden on existing staff.
The Teachers on Call has been helpful to the Marinette School District, according to Nicole Hartlaben, Shawano’s human resources director. She told the district’s finance and facilities committee Oct. 25 that it would cost the district $2,500 for setup and then a fee for each substitute teacher the agency gets.
“Essentially, it works the way a temp agency works,” Hartlaben said. “We get billed an upcharge of 30% on what we’re paying for our subs. They do all of our recruitment, hiring, and they maintain all of the unemployment tax, workers’ comp.”
Using Teachers on Call will be like having a targeted marketing effort, according to Hartlaben, and the agency will have better resources than what the district currently has.
“They already have a pool of subs that they’d be able to use in Shawano,” she said.
Rosie Thiel, the district’s current substitute coordinator, often finds herself putting in a full day as a sub herself but often has to get up early in the day and find people to fill in for other staff first.
“She actually gets up at 6 o’clock and does all this,” Hartlaben said. “She’d go back to being a permanent sub for the district. She wouldn’t lose any pay.”
Teachers on Call uses the same automated system, Front Line, that the district uses for teachers to call in when they’re not able to be at the school that day, Hartlaben said, so there would be little difficulty in transitioning. If approved by the board, it would take effect in January at the start of the second semester.
School board member Christine McKinnies noted that when she subbed as a paraprofessional, she’d get messages through Front Line to her phone several times daily letting her know what vacancies there were for the day, and then she’d select which ones she was interested in.
McKinnies questioned if it wouldn’t be better for the district if it just raised the pay for substitute teachers. Currently, sub paraprofessionals get paid $11-$12 an hour, while sub teachers get $150 per day for working one or two days in a classroom, $170 if they sub for at least a 30-day period, and $230 for long-term subbing that lasts a semester or longer.
“When I worked at the middle school as a para, and when I went subbing as a para, my hourly rate went down $3,” McKinnies said. “That’s currently $14 an hour, but if we paid the subs plus the upcharge we’d pay this company, that would be $18.20.”
Hartlaben reiterated that the 30% upcharge would be negated by the fact that Teachers on Call would handle all the bookkeeping in terms of unemployment tax and other accounting measures for the subs, which is currently being handled by district office staff.
“One other advantage is that we can bring in retired teachers (through Teachers on Call), because they’re not working for a public entity,” Hartlaben said. “We have somebody working at the middle school as a long-term sub who is going to have to take a six- to eight-week break because of WRS (Wisconsin Retirement System).”
Board member John Arens was not confident that raising pay rates would be enough to attract substitutes to work in Shawano.
“We have to look at this as, is this the cost of doing business?” Arens said. “You can raise the rates of pay all you want. You’re not going to attract the people.”
Hartlaben noted that the district had 64 open teaching or paraprofessional days during one pay period. Out of those, 31 had to be filled by staff at the school, because there are not enough substitutes available to help.
“That’s just very alarming to me to have half of our sub openings to be filled by certified staff who are giving up their prep time to do that,” Hartlaben said.
Hartlaben estimated that the district could expect to pay about $100,000 per year for Teachers on Call to fill vacancies. The proposal will go to the full board for a vote in November or December.
McKinnies noted that, in the end, she was more concerned about teacher burnout from having to work extra to compensate for missing staff than she was about having to pay a little more.
“If this is going to save our teachers having to scramble and spend a part of their lunch period or a prep period trying to cover for a missing teacher, I’m all for helping our teachers,” McKinnies said.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


