The Shawano County Board of Supervisors gave its unanimous approval July 26 to begin a process that could eventually yield two new buildings adjacent to the existing courthouse and jail in Shawano, but there’s still the question of whether that support will evaporate once the total cost is determined.
Administrative Coordinator James Davel is leading the charge to look at building a new government facility west of the courthouse and a new justice center adjacent to the west side of the jail. He estimates that, even if the county tries to fast-track the effort, it will take at least three to five years to come to fruition. The county would be seeing at least two, possibly three, election cycles take place where some supervisors step down and others are elected, but Davel feels it’s necessary to be proactive and not reactive.
“It’s imperative that the board has commitment here,” he said.
The county courthouse was built in 1956, a $1 million project that was a big commitment for the time period, but little has been done outside of necessities to improve the building. Having two separate buildings, according to Davel, will clear up safety issues, reduce costly maintenance ventures and also integrate the main branch of the Shawano County Library, whose own building is also aging rapidly with maintenance needs that are unaffordable.
County Board Chairman Thomas Kautza sees the existing courthouse as a money pit, one that will suck up more money as the facility approaches the 70-year mark.
“Sooner or later, we have to make a commitment,” Kautza said. “We’re in an old building. Yes, it’s still functional, but if you look through the (building) assessment, we’ve got to start pouring money into it.”
Earlier this year, a torrential rain caused a large amount of water to fill up the elevator shaft at the courthouse and flood parts of the courthouse’s basement level, including the county coroner’s office. The elevator alone cost the county $7,000 to repair, but there’s much more that needs to be done to keep the existing building viable, but like the library, those maintenance needs are becoming too expensive.
“It’s very hard to decide when you stop putting money into a money pit compared to something that’s going to be much more energy efficient and it’s going to last a great time,” Kautza said.
Even though the enthusiasm to grow and change is there, Davel said the county has difficulty with follow-through. He noted multiple space studies have been done, but no further action materialized because supervisors revulsed when they saw the price tag.
“You add it all up, there was $1 million, but no action was taken,” Davel said.
He added that the current courthouse is one of the few in the state that is wide open without security measures like metal detectors. Deputies from the sheriff’s department have to regularly go to the courthouse to watch over defendants from the jail or preserve the peace when problems arise.
“Court is not a 1956 court anymore,” Davel said. “There are a lot of issues in court. We’re walking our prisoners across (the street) right now.”
Davel acknowledged there’s a long road ahead, but it’s a necessary quest to avoid paying through the nose in the long run.
“I think it’s imperative that the supervisors set the conditions for success for the future of Shawano County,” Davel said.
Supervisor Jerry Erdmann strongly agreed with Davel’s assessment. A previous board chairman himself, he has seen a number of instances when the county preached change and then backpedaled, which he feels puts Shawano County back in the dark ages.
“We’ve always had plans to do certain things, but we’ve failed at the plan,” Erdmann said. “Plans don’t get us nowhere. We have to take action. Do we want to continue to throw taxpayer money away, or do we want to invest in something that will last us another half century?”
The courthouse has not only outlived its shelf life, in Davel’s view, but also its usefulness. That’s why a multi-use facility is essential, he said.
“It was built as a bomb shelter when this whole thing was done,” Davel said. “When you look at these things and you combine them, you have a heck of a problem set.”
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com
County Board OKs plan to update facilities


