Val McDermid’s “Still Life” is categorized as a “police procedural,” but it is much more than that. The story is set in Scotland with a few jaunts to France and Ireland.
Detective Chief Inspector Karen Pirie heads the Historic Cases Unit and is dedicated to finding justice for every cold case. In this book, Karen and her team find themselves tangled in three unusual cases.
First, HCU is called about a skeleton found in a van (motorhome) that has been parked inside a garage for about three years. Stella Lietch found the van and skeleton while clearing her late sister Susan’s property. The van has been wiped clean and the serial numbers removed. Damage to the skull strongly suggests foul play.
Now Karen and her assistant, DC Jason Murray, must ID the body and find the van’s owner. Susan once had a lover named Amanda McAndrews. They broke up when Amanda decided to live as a free spirit with her new lover, Dani. Stella thinks the van was Amanda’s. Would Susan store Amanda’s van knowing it contained a dead body?
Just as Karen and Jason begin their search, she gets a call to assist in a recent case. A man’s body was pulled from the Firth of Forth and his DNA connects him to an 11-year-old missing persons case. Now one of Karen’s superiors demands she solve this case fast.
At least she is given another officer. DC Daisy Mortimer is new to the force but well versed in technology. She’s also fluent in French, which will be vital in uncovering clues in both cases. Working with the French authorities, Daisy learns he was a popular jazz musician named Paul Allard. But the DNA tells them that his real name was James Auld.
Eleven years ago, James argued with this brother Iain. The next day Iain disappeared. Iain held a government office, so this was big news. The police suspected foul play and the argument made James the prime suspect. After being hounded day and night, James left Scotland for Paris. So why had he come back now?
Dividing her time and resources makes Karen’s job much more difficult, so she delegates many duties to young Jason while Daisy uncovers some valuable information on Iain Auld. Before his disappearance, Iain began an affair with eccentric but popular artist David Greig. Three weeks after Iain’s disappearance, Greig jumped off the cliffs of Firth.
By picking up the smallest thread, Daisy and Karen determine that the two men were alive and residing in Ireland. Greig has been secretly substituting his amazing fine art copies for the originals in government buildings, then selling the real paintings on the black market. Karen is sure James confronted Greig about the fraud and Greig killed him, but she needs proof or a confession.
Soon she and Daisy construct an elaborate scheme to trap both Iain and David Greig. Meanwhile, Jason has found Amanda McAndrews, but before he can contact Karen, Amanda pushes him down a stairway, leaving him to die. Daisy uses her tech skills to find Jason before it’s too late.
During all the drama, Karen must deal with her personal demons. Three years ago, her mentor/lover, Phil Parhatka, was killed apprehending Merrick Shand. Shand has been released from prison, and Karen is determined to get vengeance by haunting the man’s every move. She’s also conflicted about her relationship with Hamish McKenzie. He’s everything she wants but she fears letting him get too close. Naturally, this storyline will continue in McDermid’s next book, and I’ll definitely read it.
AT A GLANCE
Title : “Still Life” (Karen Pirie Novels, Book 6)
Author: Val McDermid
Publisher: Grove Press
Year published: 2021
Number of pages: 448
McDermid thriller is three mysteries in one


