A state appeals court last week ordered a new drunken driving trial for a Lena man because Circuit Judge Michael Judge acted as judge and jury in the case.
In overturning Jonathan E. Van Ark’s conviction, District III Court of Appeals Judge Mark Seidl found that, on a motion by the assistant district attorney, Judge improperly took the case from the jury and entered a guilty verdict.
On July 7, 2015, Judge issued his verdict, then revoked Van Ark’s license for nine months, ordered an interlock ignition device installed on his car and fined him $906. The civil penalties were not stayed pending appeal.
At trial, a state hygiene lab analyst testified that three hours after his Sept. 27, 2014, arrest, Van Ark’s blood had a .237 blood-alcohol content, nearly three times the prohibited level.
Oconto County sheriff’s deputy Adam Zahn testified that he noticed a pickup truck parked behind the Lena Fast Stop, which was closed at the time. Van Ark, 33, was behind the wheel and his eyes appeared “glossy and bloodshot” to Zahn.
Van Ark testified that he drove to the Fast Shop with the vehicle’s owner, James Van Rixel, several minutes before Zahn arrived. They were waiting there for a friend to take them to a gentlemen’s club. Van Ark also said his decision not to drive to the club had nothing to do with alcohol, as he drank about one beer an hour over six hours and did not feel impaired. Instead, Van Ark, whose wedding was upcoming, said he had a “bad feeling” about going to the club and while waiting for the friend to arrive decided not to go.
Zahn testified that he was concerned that Van Ark may be impaired, so he conducted field sobriety tests and the result prompted him to arrest Van Ark for operating while intoxicated.
After the blood test results were known, Van Ark also was charged with operating with a prohibited alcohol concentration.
After the state put on its witnesses and the defense called none, Assistant District Attorney Robert Mraz asked Judge for a directed verdict. He contended there were no disputed issues for a jury to resolve.
After hearing from Van Ark’s attorney, Barry Cohen, Judge entered a guilty verdict and sentenced Van Ark.
On appeal, Cohen argued that Judge should not have taken the case from the jury and decided Van Ark’s guilt as jurors could have rejected all or part of the testimony against his client.
Seidl concurred.
“(A)lthough the jury heard (the state analyst’s) uncontroverted testimony concerning Van Ark’s (blood-alcohol concentration), a jury is not bound by the testimony of an expert, even if uncontroverted. … Accordingly, the court erred by taking the case from the jury,” he wrote in a six-page opinion.
Cohen said it will be a “happy call” to Van Ark about the appeal, but the county can still have him retried.
Considering Van Ark’s license revocation has probably been completed, he benefits little from the appeals decision even if the county does not retry him, Cohen said.
The fine would be returned, but Van Ark’s arrest and overturned conviction may remain on his driving record if Department of Motor Vehicle regulations require it, Cohen said. However, if arrested again, the courts would consider that case his first drunken driving offense, Cohen said.
Mraz said he would not comment on the opinion.


