Skip to main content

Fire damages historic Main St. building

An historic cornerstone of Oconto Falls, in the midst of undergoing a rejuvenation effort by new ownership, was heavily damaged in a fire Wednesday. Fire broke out in the attic of The Caldwell House 1895 and spread to the second story, Oconto Falls Fire Chief Tim Magnin said Thursday morning. “It went quick,” he said. The building, located at 172 Main St., on the corner of Main Street and Caldwell Avenue, appeared to be a total loss, he said. “It’s such a sad thing, especially for someone who tired to fix it up so nice,” Magnin said. The building is owned by Oconto residents Judy and Todd Ellman and Todd’s sister, Pamela Ellman, whose vision for the facility included the newly opened Caldwell Café and the Caldwell Saloon, which was scheduled to open in a couple of months. Oconto Falls City Administrator Vicki Roberts said the city lost an important part of its history, noting that not many historic buildings remain. “We were just at a ribbon cutting a few weeks ago and talking about a revolving loan. It’s devastating,” she said. “At least nobody got hurt.” About eight tenants were displaced by the fire and were assisted by the Red Cross. Seventeen rooms on the second story were available for rent. Magnin said tenants used a fire extinguisher to put out a fire burning in a closet before they evacuated, but the fire was well out of control by this time. Firefighters were called at 10:30 p.m. When checking for tenants on the second floor, fire crews were halfway through when they left the building because fire was coming down from the ceiling, Magnin said. One firefighter required stitches for a gash on his head after he was hit by a piece of equipment will working at the water fill site, Magnin said. Because the water tower is out of commission for routine cleaning and repainting, hydrants weren’t used. Instead, water was hauled from the Oconto River. Magnin said the department had a contingency plan in place for this, and the process worked well. A dozen fire departments assisted at the fire, along with three ambulance services. Pamela Ellman was in the process having the building listed on the National Registry of Historic Places. It was built in 1895 by David Caldwell and over the years served as a boarding house and hotel. It also included a restaurant and bar. Historic records indicate Caldwell sold the business to Orrin Saunders in 1899, who renamed it Oconto Falls Hotel, and later, Saunders Hotel. Renovations were under way in the building, and on Aug. 8, a grand opening was held at the café. Pamela Ellman planned to open the Caldwell Saloon in another part of the building in a couple of months. Eight people were employed at the cafe, and Pamela Ellman was looking to hire more. She called herself the “new sheriff in town” and wore a fake mustache and sheriff’s star as a playful way to provide a fun atmosphere at the cafe. “I believe in fun. The food should be fun, the atmosphere should be fun, and the people should have fun,” she told the Times Herald in an interview last week.