Skip to main content

County remains in recycling business

Plans to scrap the county-run recycling program were put on hold Thursday by the Oconto County Board, after municipal leaders said they lacked the time and manpower to take charge of the program themselves. Supervisors, with a 25-5 vote, decided the county’s solid waste subcommittee should continue to study options for the recycling program, managed by Oconto County since the early 1990s. The subcommittee initially recommended discontinuing the program at the end of the year, but Ron Korzeniewski, chairman of the subcommittee, on Thursday instead recommended the county remain in charge. “I have never received so many phone calls, and the people I talked to want to see this program stay in business,” he said. “It’s been good for the town residents, the county residents.” Oconto Falls City Administrator Vicki Roberts asked the county board to discuss other proposals in light of the Oct. 1 deadline for municipalities to prepare documents and apply to the Department of Natural Resources for recycling grants. “There’s simply not enough time to put out RFPs (requests for proposals), have our budget approved and meet the state’s requirements and deadlines,” she said. Supervisor Diane Nichols also expressed concern about the timing, saying the rural municipalities lack the “people power to go it on their own.” Ryan Wendt, town of Brazeau chairman and county supervisor, had a different view, based on his town’s experience. Brazeau took charge of its program in 2016 without any increase in hours for its recycling employee and at little cost to its taxpayers, he said. He estimated the town would pay over $5,000 to participate in a county-run program. “Do I think other towns can do this? Of course they can,” he said. Wendt said he’s seen less garbage dumped in the ditches this year, and residents are happy with the ease of single stream recycling. The county runs a source separated system, in which recyclables can’t be mingled. Recyclables are processed at the Materials Recovery Facility in Oconto. Voting against the proposal to return the issue to committee were supervisors Wendt, Chris Augustine, Gary Frank, Richard Nelson and Don Bartels Jr. Doug McMahon was absent. Oconto County has run the recycling program since recycling was mandated by state law, partnering with municipalities to collect, process and market recyclables, plus handle all the red tape associated with the program. Recyclables include tin, plastic, paper, cardboard and glass. The county also processes other materials not allowed in landfills, such as car batteries, tires, scrap metal, E-waste such as computers and TVs, and major appliances. In 2015, all but two municipalities agreed to a one-year extension of the most recent five-year recycling agreement with the county. The city of Gillett and town of Brazeau decided to run their own recycling programs for 2016, and the city of Oconto and the towns of Lakewood, Townsend and Underhill will go this route for 2017. As municipalities defect, it leaves less grant funding available to cover program costs for the remaining municipalities and less recyclable material to be marketed, said Pat Virtues, head of the Oconto County Planning, Zoning and Solid Waste Department. In addition, state grants have decreased and commodity prices have eroded over time, leaving a program once profitable and self-sufficient, now projected to cost an estimated $225,000 a year. Frank said municipalities who contract with the county should be aware of this cost. “The towns and municipalities that want to continue with this need to realize the county will not pick up that cost. That $225,000 is going to come out of their budgets,” he said. The municipalities might choose to tax residents for recycling costs, he said. “We have no room in our budget to pay part of their responsibility,” he said. “The cost and the burden of this has to be with the users, by those generating the recyclables,” Supervisor Alan Sleeter said. “It has to be passed on to them.” Elmer Ragen, town of Little Suamico chairman and county supervisor, said 60 percent of the residents in his town already pay a private company for door-to-door pick up. “If it goes on their tax roll, they’re paying it again,” he said. Little Suamico may decide to go with 100 percent door-to-door collection, but Ragen said he wanted a few years for his town to study its options. According to information provided by the county’s finance department, the recycling program has not used tax dollars to operate the program since 2001. The county has relied on an enterprise fund, built with grant money and the sale of commodities, to cover losses in the program in recent years. The average operating loss over the past four years has been $131,144.