Fans of mixed martial arts will learn over the coming weeks whether Conor McGregor takes an early retirement, as suggested in a recent tweet he made, or he attempts to avenge a defeat he suffered earlier this year.
McGregor is a 27-year-old Irishman who’d emerged over the past two years as the sport’s brightest star. A smaller, paler version of Muhammad Ali, he is a supreme trash talker with skill to back up the noise – the perfect merging of attributes for the pay-per-view combat scene. Whether he retires, or returns to his old face-smashing ways, will be closely examined.
There may not be much more written about Joao Carvalho’s last bout, though, and in light of his story having run more than a week ago, it might already be washed out of the news cycle.
Carvalho was the 28-year-old fighter from Portugal who died from brain injuries suffered in a fight with Ireland’s Charlie Ward.
In the wake of his death there were smattering, token calls for the prohibiting of the sport, on the grounds that, like boxing, it’s unsafe.
The basic argument is that, for we fragile hominids there isn’t a great future in getting smacked on the head over and over. The neurological chickens will come home to roost. Over the past 125 years, boxing has produced more than 900 ring-related deaths, on top of the cavalcade of fight veterans with speech and memory problems.
The argument in favor of the existence of professional mixed martial arts has merit: The Ultimate Fighting Championship circuit provides a legitimate career avenue for martial arts experts and college wrestlers who crossed over to UFC, where before there was no such opportunity.
The difference is the issue of the head shots that MMA competitors absorb on a regular basis, and the cumulative effects thereof.
Concussions are such a hot-button issue in the National Football League today that there is a neurologist on hand at every NFL game. In society’s recent noggin-awareness push, there also have been important questions raised about the dangers of repeated headers in soccer.
Often, it takes a tragedy to bring about a departure from conventional beliefs. In the 1960s, high school football coaches were known to taunt players at summer practice, to the effect of, “Might as well drink the sweat coming off your forehead ‘cause that’s all you’re gonna get!”
In the prevailing wisdom of that era, coaches went full Spartan on their teenage warriors. Denying them the water they craved could only make them stronger and tougher competitors. Right?
Then players started dropping dead of dehydration at practice, and it sunk in that burning up athletes from the inside wasn’t such a super idea, and that a drink of water during practice for kids wearing full pads in 90-degree heat was actually a good thing.
But change in conventional thinking doesn’t mean a sport is going away. They will still play games and host fights, only presented as more safety-oriented. If 900 deaths inside the ring haven’t stopped the fight game, don’t look for much movement on No. 901. Bread and circuses are still required fare.
Nor should MMA be decreed away. In a perfect world, there is neither need nor place for a sport in which two people with no personal history between them meet to decide which one can rip the head off the other. But we have what we have. Competitors should just walk away from the sport when they’ve decided it’s the wise move.
Families like the Carvalhos will spend a lot of time wishing they’d urged another avenue for their fallen battler, but in the final analysis they know it might’ve fallen on deaf ears anyway. MMA is tough in every sense, right down to its being a tough way to make a living.


