Skip to main content

Book label dispute sent back to square one

Shawano County Library patrons upset with the relabeling of Christian fiction books as inspirational materials will have to go back to square one with their complaints. Members of the library board agreed Nov. 13 that to be fair to anyone with concerns over library materials, the same process must be followed by all. That means, those upset with the relabeling must first complete a “materials reconsideration form” and send it to the library director. After the director responds in writing, and only if the patron disagrees with the director’s decision, he or she can, again in writing, appeal to the library board. “The process did not begin with the reconsideration form at all,” said Nancy Bell, library director. “It kind of jumped our process and policy in that way.” This policy is spelled out on the library website, but the form is only available at the library. Officials will work to rectify that. It’s expected that if residents officially file their concerns soon, the appeal would be in front of the board at the Dec. 11 meeting. Several residents were present at meeting and asked why none of this was noted when there were so many more present at the October board meeting. Board member Sharon Beversdorf said not everyone on the board was aware of the process until now. She also reminded audience members the decision was not made by the board and that Bell has only been on the job for six weeks. “We honestly don’t know who made this decision,” she said. State Rep. Peter Schmidt said numerous residents have contacted him about the issue. “I’m in the process of drafting a bill that would give guidance to libraries not to degrade religious material,” he said. Schmidt provided examples of Christian fiction books with different labels. “I’d like to see where the confusion is with labeling, because it’s not consistent,” he said. “I’d like to work together with the library board, because I know the national library association, they have a different interpretation of what religious freedom means. While Wisconsin encourages all religion to be treated equally, while the federal advisory, they want to throw religion out of our public institutions and libraries.” Board member Gina Shatters was the first to bring up the issue in October. “If someone wrote a Muslim fiction book, I would hope that this board would say, ‘It’s Muslim fiction. That’s the way that that label should be written.’ Because that’s what right.” Bell also pointed that the American Library Association (ALA), which has put forth the labeling guidelines that are at the cater of this debate, is a professional association, and the Shawano County Library does not belong to it. While the local library’s mission statement and some policies indicate the library will follow the recommendations of the ALA, there are no requirements that any or all recommendations be followed. Also, there are no enforcement penalties if the recommendations are not followed. kpasson@newmedia-wi.com