Rep. Peter Schmidt is the co-sponsor for a pair of legislative projects that, if they get past the Wisconsin Legislature and Gov. Tony Evers, are expected to make a huge impact on the income of his constituents in the 6th Assembly District.
Dubbed the “Returning Your Surplus” legislation, it would reduce the middle-income tax rate by almost a full percentage point, and the average filer would see a decrease of $772 per year. The legislation also includes the creation of a tax-free retirement, a setup similar to what’s offered in nearby Iowa and Illinois, and would exempt single filers up to $100,000 and joint filers up to $150,000.
The income tax cut would mean that taxes for income between $27,630 and $304,170 for individuals, and between $36,840 and $405,550 for married couples, would drop from 5.3% to 4.4%.
“There are currently nine states that don’t tax income at all,” Schmidt said.
Evers vetoed that same income tax cut in the state budget. He has said he was open to reconsidering cutting taxes if Republicans would look at funding some of his priorities. Evers called a special session for the legislature to spend more than $1 billion for child care, the University of Wisconsin System, worker shortage programs and other areas.
Schmidt said in an interview with NEW Media that the Republicans have tweaked the income tax cut to focus mainly on the middle class instead of providing a tax cut across the board that included the highest bracket, which he believes Evers will be more amenable to supporting.
The income tax cut would be especially beneficial to communities where spring school district referenda are being considered, such as Shawano, Schmidt said. He noted that giving more money back to residents will be helpful if school districts pass referenda that will increase taxes at the local level.
“Shawano’s looking at $93 million,” Schmidt said. “That’s going to be a big tax hike. I’ve got constituents in Shawano who are thinking, ‘We should leave,’ and cash out. It might sound like a little bit, but if you talk to the middle-class families, it’s unaffordable.”
As for the tax-free retirement, Schmidt believes it will get bipartisan support in the Assembly, noting that the legislation passed in Illinois with a Democratic majority in its legislature, and Iowa with a Republican majority.
“If you’re single, it’ll be the first $100,000 of your retirement income tax-free, which is your 401Ks and your prior entitlements,” Schmidt said. “Your Roth will not be included because that’s already pre-taxed. Individuals have the option to take tax credits or do it this way. They can’t go back and forth.”
He added that any work income retirees earn while receiving retirement benefits will still be taxed. This will not affect federal taxes on retirement income, Schmidt said.
“That’s where the income tax cut comes in,” he said. “There are a lot of senior citizens that are working part-time, because they can’t afford their retirement due to the increase in taxes and inflation. This is a compromise bill where we can use the state surplus and give it back to the hard-working taxpayers.”
Schmidt noted that a majority of people in the 6th Assembly District are considered to be senior citizens, so the tax-free retirement will impact a large swath of his constituents.
“We have a population that’s retiring or has moved into that phase,” Schmidt said. “They’re moving toward that fixed income.”
Senior citizens who might be looking to downsize to something more affordable can’t do so right now because of high interest rates on mortgages and continued inflation, according to Schmidt.
“A lot of senior citizens do not want to downsize with the mortgage rate being around 8%,” Schmidt said, noting it’s at a 23-year high. “This tax cut will alleviate some of that, because this will be retroactive to the start of 2023. When everyone files their taxes, they’re going to get a bigger refund, because it goes back to the first of the year.”
The retroactive start date will include the income tax cut, as well, he said.
The total tax-cut effort is expected to use up about $2.9 billion of the state’s current surplus of $4 billion, according to Schmidt.
With both proposals being announced Aug. 29, they must go through legislative committees and then to the full Assembly, followed by the Senate and then to Evers’ desk. Schmidt noted that details could change between now and then.
“We’ll see how it looks once it gets through the process,” he said.
Schmidt was less enthusiastic about supporting Evers’ ideas for the surplus, including worker shortage and child care programs.
“Growing the government is not good long-term, and we’ve seen what happens,” Schmidt said. “As government gets bigger, people lose their liberties.”
The Associated Press contributed to this story.


