The Menominee Indian Tribe cannot grow industrial hemp on its reservation, a federal judge has ruled while rejecting the tribe’s argument that it should be treated similarly to a state.
U.S. District Judge William Griesbach ruled that the tribe must abide by a federal law that permits growing hemp — which is similar to marijuana — only where it is allowed by state law.
Hemp farming is not legal in Wisconsin, but Menominee tribal leaders declared it legal on their reservation and then planted a crop that was raided and seized by federal drug agents last October.
The tribe responded by filing a civil suit against the federal government and asking a judge to rule that the tribe was within its rights to pursue hemp as a potential new source of revenue for the impoverished tribe north of Shawano.
In a ruling issued Monday, Griesbach threw out the tribe’s case, likening the federal hemp law to one authorizing native American gambling casinos only in states were such gambling is permitted.
“It is not unusual for Congress to incorporate state law as the standard for conduct allowed on Indian lands,” the judge stated.
Menominee tribal leaders issued a statement expressing disappointment in the judge’s decision, but offered no clear indication whether the tribe planned to appeal. The statement was issued by the office of tribal Chairwoman Joan Delabreau.
“The tribe is disappointed with this recent setback that challenges our sovereignty as a tribal nation and inhibits our ability to pursue research initiatives exploring the viability of this versatile and sustainable crop,” the statement said. “The tribe is currently reviewing the decision to determine what options it may or may not pursue.”
The dispute stemmed from an Oct. 23 raid conducted on the Menominee reservation by the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration. Agents later reported that they confiscated and destroyed about 30,000 marijuana plants, some up to 6 feet tall.
Tribal officials disputed that the crop was marijuana, insisting that it was industrial hemp, a milder form of the cannabis plant used legally in such commercial products as clothing, paper and detergents.
Whether it was marijuana or hemp was not an issue in the tribe’s civil suit filed in federal court in Green Bay.
In its suit, the tribe argued that its crop should be permitted because of the federal law allowing hemp farming in states where it is legal. Attorneys for the tribe pointed out that the state of Wisconsin since the 1970s has allowed the Menominee tribal government to enforce its own criminal laws free from state jurisdiction.
Attorneys for the federal government argued that Congress exhibited no intent to extend the same hemp-farming rights to native American tribes as it did to states.
The judge heard oral arguments May 13 in Green Bay.
On some procedural issues raised in the case, Griesbach ruled in the tribe’s favor. However, he granted the government’s motion to dismiss the case, and he rejected the tribe’s motion for summary judgment, on the grounds that the federal law is clear that industrial hemp can be grown only where state laws allow it — and nowhere they do not.
Acknowledging the “unique trust relationship” that native American tribes have with the U.S. government, Griesbach wrote that many federal statutes involving tribal governments are construed liberally in favor of the tribes when challenged in court.
“Tribal sovereignty is preserved,” he wrote, “unless Congress’ intent to the contrary is clear.”


