A state appeals court on May 10 upheld a Shawano man’s double homicide convictions and consecutive life sentences involving his ex-mistress and her brother.
The District III Court of Appeals rejected Daniel L. Schmidt’s claims that there was insufficient evidence to convict him; the trial judge erred in allowing his wife to testify; and police used suggestive interviewing techniques to influence testimony from a victim’s son.
Schmidt’s attorney said he will appeal the decision to the Wisconsin Supreme Court.
Schmidt, 32, was charged in Oconto County Circuit Court with two counts of intentional homicide after Kimberly Rose and her brother, Leonard Marsh, were found dead from shotgun wounds on the morning of May 19, 2009, in the town of Gillett home that they shared.
At his sentencing, Schmidt offered his condolences and prayers to the family of Rose and Marsh, but offered no apology.
“I can’t apologize for something I did not do,” he said.
According to testimony at the trial, Schmidt and Rose began an affair in November 2008, but Schmidt later ended the relationship and tried to mend his marriage with his wife, Stephanie. Special Prosecutor Richard Dufour said Schmidt went to the Gillett home on May 19, 2009, shot Rose in the face and neck to stop her from disrupting his marriage and shot Marsh three times in the back, while he laid in bed, because he was a witness to the murder.
The jury at Schmidt’s trial also viewed clips of an interview in which Schmidt talked about a journal written by Rose that reportedly included graphic details of their sexual relationship.
Stephanie Schmidt wanted to read the entries and planned to go to Rose’s home May 21 to see the diary, according to the testimony. She testified at trial that she was heartbroken by the affair and, in discussing it five days before the murders, Schmidt told her “I’d like to shoot (Rose), then myself.”
She also testified that Schmidt had a rusty 20-gauge shotgun and talked about getting rid of it after the murders because it could implicate him. Two days after the murders Stephanie said she saw a new shotgun at their residence and Schmidt said he had given away the old gun to someone who had destroyed it.
On appeal, Schmidt’s attorney, Timothy Provis, attacked Stephanie Schmidt’s testimony that he said he wanted to kill Rose, arguing it was privileged communication between spouses and should not have been heard by the jury.
Instead, the District III Court found that Schmidt waived this martial privilege when he told police that he told Stephanie that he wanted to kill himself, even though he denied saying he wanted to kill Rose.
Schmidt told police a “significant” portion of his conversation with Stephanie and it contained an important sequence — he wanted to kill Rose, then himself, according to the appeals opinion.
“The two aspects of Schmidt’s statement are not as easily separated as Schmidt suggests, such that Schmidt’s admission to telling Stephanie he wanted to kill himself was a disclosure of a ‘significant part’ of the total statement,” waiving his marital privilege, Judge Thomas Hruz wrote in the 39-page opinion.
The appeals court also found the state presented sufficient evidence to support the murder allegations against Schmidt.
The state’s theory of the case was that Schmidt drove to Rose’s residence to confront her about the affair and her unhappiness with Schmidt’s attempt to repay a $1,000 loan with marijuana.
Schmidt’s uncle, Keith Schmidt, testified that Stephanie said Rose demanded Schmidt repay the loan in full after she discovered Schmidt had told Stephanie about the affair.
Provis also challenged Circuit Judge Michael Judge’s decision to exclude an expert for the defense who would testify about the influence police could have had on Rose’s son, Donovan, and his recollection of events before the murders.
Donovan was 11 years old when his mother was murdered, and since the state had no eye witnesses to the crime or a murder weapon, his testimony was important, according to the appeals opinion.
He testified about hearing his mother and a man argue the night before the murders and recognizing Schmidt’s truck parked outside the house.
However, portions of Donovan’s testimony changed during the three times law enforcement interviewed him, and the defense was entitled to have an expert testify on how the reliability of the boy’s statements could be affected by police inappropriately questioning him, Provis argued.
The appeals court disagreed, finding the defense expert’s testimony was irrelevant because he never met Donovan and there were no recordings or transcripts made of the police interviews to determine if they used inappropriate questioning techniques.
Oconto County District Attorney Edward Burke said the opinion was “good law.”
“This is well-established law. The only twist is in the partial disclosure of martial privilege; that is cutting edge, but it’s good law and good for the county,” he said.
Provis said he would petition the Wisconsin Supreme Court to hear the marital privilege issue he raised.
“There’s been no definitive interpretation of that by the Wisconsin Supreme Court, and since the case has been recommended for publication (which would give it precedential value), it may interest the (state’s high court),” he said.
Schmidt is serving his sentence at Waupun Correctional Institution, according to online records.


