Virginia Misco admits she was nervous, but she sure didn’t show it.
The Oconto Falls High School catcher was at the plate in the bottom of the seventh inning with one out in a tie ballgame against Fox Valley Lutheran. Michaela Thomson stood at second base as the potential game-winning run.
“Virginia was probably the girl I wanted up there,” Oconto Falls softball coach Nick Tolzman said. “She’s been one of our better hitters all year.”
As Foxes ace Sam Birling threw a 3-1 pitch, Misco turned on it for a walkoff 4-3 victory at home on Thursday, May 19.
“She came right across the plate, and I have trouble getting ahead of myself, so I just pulled back and it felt just nice and smooth,” Misco said.
Misco punched it through the infield into center and Thomson got the green light by Tolzman to try and score.
“I think Thomson would agree she’s not the fastest runner on our team, but she had a tremendous jump,” Tolzman said. “When she got off second and I looked up and she was right to third, I knew she had a great opportunity to beat it out.”
Thomson beat the throw to the plate and the Oconto Falls players rejoiced in the team’s regular-season finale.
“I didn’t know if she was going to go or not, and I didn’t know if she was going to be out or not, but then she was safe, and I was excited,” Misco said.
It was a comeback win for the Panthers, who trailed by one run on three instances in the North Eastern Conference game. The winning run was Oconto Falls’ only lead of the day.
The score was knotted at 2 entering the seventh when Fox Valley Lutheran scored one run off Oconto Falls relief pitcher MaKenna Kussow. The Foxes ended up stranding runners at second and third with one out to keep it 3-2.
That set the stage for the Panthers’ rally in the bottom of the frame. Stephanie Peitersen got a one-out single to right and moved to second on a passed ball. Thomson singled, and Peitersen advanced to third. Back to the top of the order, Bailey Magnin hit a weak ground ball to the first baseman who opted to throw home to try and cut down the tying run, but Peitersen slid underneath the tag, which set up Misco’s late-game heroics.
Going into the inning down a run, Tolzman was confident his team could pull off the victory.
“I think I had a lot of belief in our hitters, because we were making pretty good contact from the fourth inning on – the Ks were going away,” Tolzman said. “Once you make contact, usually good things happen. Obviously, my senior came through in the clutch, Thomson, with a huge hit to tie the game. I felt like once we tied the game, the pressure was kind of off and it was more then on them.”
Fox Valley Lutheran (7-12, 8-9 NEC) scored once in the fourth to take the lead. However, Oconto Falls (6-14, 6-12 NEC) answered right back as Sadie Pankratz drove home Magnin, who led off the inning with a double.
In the fifth, the Foxes tallied a run, but, again, Oconto Falls had an answer. Peitersen struck out with one gone, but the ball got away from the catcher to allow Peitersen to reach base. She came around to score on a Magnin base hit.
Magnin was 2-for-4 with an RBI and run scored. Oconto Falls had eight hits as a team.
Tolzman decided to throw two pitchers in the game. His daughter, Josie, went the first four innings and allowed one run, four hits and struck out two. Kussow threw the final three innings and picked up the victory. She gave up one earned run, four hits and recorded one strikeout.
“I was happy that Kussow got back on track,” coach Tolzman said. “The last couple of outings were rough. But I believed in her enough to put her in a 1-1 ball game in the fifth inning, and she threw three fantastic innings.”
The Panthers entered Tuesday’s WIAA Division 2 regional against Southern Door as winners of three of their last four games. They want to use that momentum in their favor. Tuesday’s game results were not available prior to the Times Herald deadline.
“It’s nice to go in with a win, to have something behind our back,” Misco said. “But we just have to put it behind us like the wins and the losses, and just look forward to the next game.”


