Skip to main content

Falls seeks electricity rate increase

The Oconto Falls Light and Water Commission wants to increase average residential electric bills by $3.14 per month by doubling the customer charge but cutting rates 6 percent, according to a rate application recently filed with the Wisconsin Public Service Commission. Average residential customers pay a $7 fixed monthly charge plus an energy charge for kilowatt hours of power used. The utility seeks to double the fixed charge to $14 monthly. The energy charge fluctuates with the wholesale cost of electricity. Like authorities at other Wisconsin utilities, local officials want to shift the cost of maintaining poles, wire and other infrastructure assets from the energy charge to the fixed charge, saying it better reflects the cost of doing business. The PSC has largely complied with granting increases in monthly customer charges to investor-owned utilities, including a 75 percent increase to Xcel Energy in December 2015, hiking charges from $8 to $14; a 55 percent increase to WE Energies in November 2014, hiking charges from $9 to $16; and an 83 percent increase to WPS in November 2014, hiking charges from $10.40 to $19. Madison Gas & Electric received a nearly identical increase ($10.50 to $19) in November 2014. Municipal-owned utilities seem to be following the trend. Waupun Utilities, for example, has a 50 percent customer charge increase request pending with the PSC. Greg Kuhn, Oconto Falls’ utility manager, declined to discuss the utility’s rate application with a reporter but replied by email to questions. Kuhn wrote that the utility determined that the fixed charge needed updating to $14 monthly to ensure “we can reliably and sustainably serve our customers for the long term.” In a recent cost of service study, the utility determined the range of what it costs to deliver electricity to homes can range from $11 to $29 per customer. “In the past, utilities have been subsidizing this fee with kilowatt per hour usage fees and now the PSC would like to see those costs get recuperated through a fixed fee as they should be,” Kuhn wrote. Kuhn noted the increased customer charge would be mostly offset by decreased electric rates. Bills for average residential customers who use 559 kilowatt hours of power monthly would increase from $78.90 to $82.04, about 4 percent. Critics of electric utilities’ increasing reliance on fixed charges say it reduces incentives for customers to invest in solar or wind power as the new rate structures increase the payback period for that investment. Not many Oconto Falls customers have invested in alternative energy facilities, Kuhn wrote, and the utility is asking the PSC to end the solar renewable distribution tariff for lack of customer participation. Customers generating electricity with solar installations could sell power back to the utility at higher than usual rates. The program was offered through the utility’s wholesale power supplier, WPPI, and was fully subscribed without any local customers signing up for it, Kuhn wrote. Instead, residential, small business and industrial customers have participated in the Focus on Energy conservation programs that promote energy savings through use of LED lighting. Focus on Energy and the Oconto Falls utility have contributed funds to help defray the cost to acquire and install some energy-saving equipment, Kuhn wrote. Since 2011, about 90 percent of the electric utility’s residential meters have been converted to automated ones, which cut meter reading costs and supplies usage data at more frequent intervals, Kuhn wrote. Commercial customers are also receiving “smart meters,” which allow them to better understand their usage, conserve energy and lower their power costs, Kuhn wrote. The conversion is estimated to cost $135,000 and will save the utility $9,000 annually in meter reading and associated costs once the project is complete. The utility is also seeking an economic rate that would benefit new businesses or manufacturing plants. “By offering this rate, businesses looking to establish themselves in our community would be given a rate designed to help curb start-up costs and get them up and running,” Kuhn wrote. If approved as submitted, the new rates would boost utility annual revenue by $124,141 to an estimated $3.502 million. Total annual expenses are projected at $3.103 million, leaving the utility with an annual net operating income of $399,000 and a 5.5 percent rate of return on the net value of its infrastructure investment, according to the application. PSC staff will review the rate application, recommend an amount of revenue it determines the utility needs to remain financially viable and hold a public hearing simultaneously in Oconto Falls and Madison before the commission sets new rates. The process could take several months. The PSC last increased the utility’s rates by 2.16 percent in 2013.