As much as public servants want things to go in an orderly fashion — meetings, as an example — they don’t always go that way. When things go awry, it is usually up to leaders to try and resolve any conflicts that might occur.
If the Menominee Indian School District’s budget hearing is an example of how to bring everyone together, then School Board President David Miller might want to take a refresher course. Things were about as calm as a hurricane at times during the meeting, and instead of trying to instill goodwill with the public, which could easily vote in a future election to remove him from office, he chose to show disdain toward the people who chose to disagree with him and the board on the budget.
Let’s start with the comments from Gregg Malmstrom, who argued that the audience of about 80 had very little information about how the district was going to spend the local tax levy. Less than two minutes in, Miller said that comments would be limited to five minutes. Miller’s comments might be warranted after four minutes in, maybe four minutes and 30 seconds, but to do it less than 40% through a time limit that was never announced to the public indicated Miller didn’t like Malmstrom’s commentary and was trying to shut him down.
Don’t take my word for it, though. Here’s what Miller responded when Malmstrom claimed he hadn’t used up five minutes of the meeting: “Well, you better summarize quick there.”
If Miller wants others to respect the process of a public meeting, perhaps he should look at his own behavior, because that was, by no means, a respectful response.
It didn’t stop there, though. Another audience member asked what the ground rules were for the meeting and if they were printed somewhere. Instead of answering the gentleman’s question, Miller’s response was, “As you can see, the annual meeting is scheduled for 5 p.m. We can sit here and talk all night, but I’m just saying five minutes per person, because there could be other questions.”
In other words, he was making it up as he went along. Why else would he not spell out what the ground rules for the meeting and answer if they were in some written form somewhere?
Another audience member asked how discussion could take place on the budget without everyone present having that information, to which Miller dismissively said: “If we want to get back to it, are there any questions?” and completely ignored that audience member.
She brought up her point again a few minutes later when a staff member suggested looking at the written report, and Miller suggested that she exit the auditorium and return later when she had the information. If it’d been me, I would have suggested pausing the hearing until additional copies of the budget report had been made and distributed to those present. After all, this is an educational institution, and isn’t knowledge the name of the game, or was the school board looking for a rubber stamp from the audience, who was being viewed as simpletons?
Miller’s piece de resistance came after the audience member objected to his flippant attitude and she told him not to make her request into a joke, to which he retorted: “Well, don’t make a joke out of our meeting here. We’re just asking for some civility here.”
Hypocrisy is not a good look for Miller. He spent several minutes maligning three residents who were there to vote on the district’s tax levy and then had the gall to claim they were the ones being uncivil. Wanting full disclosure before making a decision on such an important matter and saying that a legitimate conversation can’t take place without that information is not an indication of barbarism — it’s a sign of intelligence.
It’s no wonder that, once the time came to elect a chairperson for the annual meeting, Miller lost to a non-school board member, Kathy Bahr, when she received 45 votes. It was clear that the audience had enough of Miller’s bad attitude and wanted someone else to run the meeting, and it was clear there was mistrust with the school district when the motion to approve the tax levy lost by two votes, 28-26.
If the attitude Miller conveys with the public reflects his attitude at the annual meeting, it would seem there’s ample cause for concern that some of the people who claimed they don’t trust the district have a valid point. Whether the rest of the school board shares Miller’s attitude is unclear, as most were silent throughout the meeting.
The exception was Lloyd Friesen, who took time to explain why insurance was needed for legal proceedings. He took the time to explain that not doing so would put the district in a precarious position where, in the event of losing a lawsuit, it would shelling out money for fines and restitution instead of paying teachers and staff to educate future generations.
Miller might want to reflect on his actions at the annual meeting and make efforts to change his attitude. Treating people in the school district who pay taxes and send their children to the schools like they’re beneath contempt is not a good thing when you have a number of people who feel you’re not telling them the truth. Sucking it up and being transparent is the way to go, and if Miller decides not to take that path, I wish him luck when his seat is up for election.
Lee Pulaski is the city editor for NEW Media. Readers can contact him at lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com.


