Why do I keep selecting cozy mysteries? I swear most of them are written by the same author using the same plot! Thirty-something single gal running a small business, a murder, a villain, a sweet friend/family member, a handsome police officer/detective and a bunch of suspects. She is told to butt out but just can’t/won’t listen.
This time, the book was “All Work and No Slay” by Skye Sullivan. It is the first in her Devil’s Orchard series.
Set in far northern California, Devil’s Orchard is a popular tourist destination. Bobbi Brooks lives with her “mother” and runs Devil’s Lunchbox, a niche business serving bento box meals. She also offers hiking tours on the many oceanside trails. The day Bobbi turned 33, her mother confessed that she was actually her grandmother but refused to say more.
Granny also discloses that she and Bobbi are witches assigned to the slaying demons who sneak through a rift between worlds. The creatures are ravenous and cannot be satiated, so every living thing is in danger. Bobbi needs a lot of training before she can tackle demons on her own, but a recent demon infestation forces her to rush things.
Juggling her business and her “side identity” have Bobbi frazzled, so she’s not really surprised to be joined by a fox vixen named Kitsune. Kitsune explains that she is a “familiar” sent to serve Bobbi. And she’ll need help when she opens her walk-in freezer and finds the body of her landlord, Christopher Boyd.
The man has been trying to void Bobbi’s lease so he can greatly increase the rent. Boyd’s not popular around Devil’s Orchard, but would someone kill him? Suddenly Bobbi’s struggling business is a crime scene, complete with paramedics and police.
Officer Grant Daniels and Bobbi have a long history. They were best friends back when Grant was a tall, skinny, geeky teenager. Years in the Marine Corps have transformed him into a real hunk. Now he’s returned to Devil’s Orchard as a police officer and with a supermodel girlfriend, Miranda. Granny insists that he and Bobbi belong together, but Bobbi refuses to even think about it.
The gossip mill quickly puts Bobbi and Granny Lydia at the top of the suspect list, so Bobbi decides it is up to her to clear their names. As expected, she’s told to back off, but also as expected, she starts to dig. It doesn’t take long to come up with a list of suspects with both motive and means.
With the help of her newfound magic, Bobbi learns about Boyd’s hopes to develop the area near where Bobbi and Lydia live. That deal includes investors Miranda and her brother.
Bobbi dutifully shares all information and suspicions with Grant without telling him she’s a witch. He listens but insists that the situation is dangerous for her and her grandmother. She wants to listen but can’t resist following up on one more lead. Then she realizes she’s been misdirected so the killer could get to Granny.
She sends Grant to their home but knows she’ll need her witchcraft to save Granny and Kitsune. She arrives to find the killer brandishing a gun, Granny standing on a chair with a noose around her neck and Kitsune out cold. As the motive for Boyd’s killing is revealed, Bobbi realizes the killer is not only trying to frame her Granny, that person is also going to kill her. It’s going to take an inexperienced Bobbi’s best spell to save the day.
When all is said and done, life in Devil’s Orchard can carry on — unaware of the witches who protect them from devastation, both human and demon.
As frustrating as some plots are, I guess I’ll just keep reading whatever I find. Your public library has books worth your time. Go in and check it out.
AT A GLANCE
Book: “All Work and No Slay” (Witches of Devil’s Orchard, Book 1)
Author: Skye Sullivan
Publisher: Skye Sullivan
Year published: 2021
Number of pages: 299
Cozy mystery has familiar plot


