To the editor:
It has come to our attention that Oconto Falls is scheduled to conduct a goose cull on June 30. We’re concerned that city officials failed to thoroughly explore effective nonlethal remedies prior to approving the cull.
The size of a goose flock is dictated by the extent of food available to it. If the birds are physically removed from the flock, by culling for example, this not only increases the food supply for the remainder of the flock, but also creates a void, which is filled by surviving members of the flock.
We understand and appreciate that city officials are often called upon to “control” pest species in suburban areas. Concerned residents may demand action while not always understanding the true nature of the “pest” problems.
A rushed response to these demands for action can lead to inhumane and ineffective control, breaches of current legislation and wasted funds. A clear and well-informed policy, together with accurate assessments of the impact of these species, will enable relevant departments to respond effectively.
Culling geese is rarely an effective long-term solution — which is why councils that embark on this route often find they are calling the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service over and over again.
I believe we would all prefer to use humane, nonlethal techniques to solve any problems. Killing 200 animals just because they cause a nuisance is a disproportionate response to the problem.
Trapping and shooting are the most common methods of lethal control for Canadian geese, which can be particularly cruel as these birds generally mate for life. Shooting can pose a risk to other birds and the public, particularly in urban areas.
During the molt (where they shed feathers rendering them temporarily flightless), geese will be rounded up and then shot. This is extremely stressful and distressing for those geese who witness the deaths of their fellow birds, including their mate.
Canada geese are invariably very popular with the public, which also finds shooting distasteful and distressing.
The Goose Conservation Society states, “The shooting of adult birds, as well as being cruel, is not an effective means of reducing the numbers of Canada Geese, since more birds will always fly into the territory.”
Geese choose very specific environments in which to make their homes. Making the area less appealing is often key to deterring them, and a multi-faceted approach that employs many or all of the effective techniques together is likely to yield the best result.
Jordan W. Turner
President, Global Conservation Group
Global Conservation LLC, Watertown


