Alcohol use and the lack of seat belts were factors in two fatal crashes in Shawano County last month that took the lives of three people, the Shawano County Sheriff’s Department said.
Detective Chris Gamm, who performed the accident reconstructions on the two crashes, revealed the details during an interview Tuesday with the Leader.
Release of the cause of the accidents had been awaiting the results of toxicology tests.
Two people were killed in a single-vehicle crash on Lake Drive in the town of Wescott on May 9.
Rocco Spinelli, 36, of Oconto, was driving northbound on County Road H/Lake Drive and Old Lake Lane when he lost control of the vehicle, causing it to enter the ditch and strike several trees.
Spinelli and his passenger — Jacob Thorne, 22, of Bonduel — passed away from the injuries they sustained in the crash.
“In that crash, it was determined that excessive speed and alcohol were factors,” Gamm said.
Gamm also said neither of them was wearing seat belts.
In the second crash, on May 15, Dr. Robert Fischer, 80, of Shawano, was killed in a two-vehicle, head-on crash on County Road D, just north of County Road DD, in the town of Pella.
Fischer had been northbound on County Road D, crossed the center line and collided with a southbound vehicle being operated by Michael Harbath, 63, of Clintonville.
Harbath and his passenger, along with a passenger in Fischer’s vehicle, were injured in the crash.
Gamm said the cause of that crash was “a medical condition and alcohol use.”
He said there was no way of knowing which was the primary factor.
“One complicates the other,” he said.
Gamm also said there was no seat belt use in Fischer’s vehicle. Harbath was also unbelted, he said.
“The crash involving Mr. Fischer was a survivable crash,” Gamm said. “The lack of seat belt use, in my opinion, was a major factor in that crash becoming a fatality.”
The crash occurred at speeds that were under the speed limit, Gamm said.
Gamm said that in his roughly 20 years with the department he has responded to more than 60 fatality crashes. He is now typically the department’s lead detective in crash reconstruction and investigation.
He estimated that the lack of seat belts played a role in 75 percent of those fatalities. More than 50 percent, he said, were alcohol-related.
Shawano County has seen three fatal crashes so far this year, resulting in four deaths, compared to five fatalities in 2015.
Those numbers are down significantly from the years when Gamm first started with the department, when it would not have been unusual to see as many as 20 fatalities in a year.
Gamm said the numbers have been reduced by aggressive enforcement of drunken driving laws and laws mandating seat belt use.
However, he added, “seat belt use in Wisconsin is still very low.”
Sheriff Adam Bieber said seat belt use is a takeaway from these crashes that authorities want to emphasize.
“It’s just proven to save lives, over and over,” he said.
He also acknowledged the role alcohol played in both crashes.
“We are constantly working on trying to educate the public on driving sober,” he said, adding that deputies made more OWI arrests in 2014 than the year before.
“People just have to educate themselves and provide rides for one another,” he said.
Ironically, according to Bieber, Thorne had tried to do that prior to the crash that took his life.
“That’s what that one kid was doing,” Bieber said. “He was calling around for a ride. He just happened to call a guy that was already intoxicated, though.”
Thorne was known to the Bonduel community as an accomplished athlete at Bonduel High School.
He was a member of the Bonduel Bears conference championship team as a senior and went on to play college basketball at Wisconsin Lutheran College in Milwaukee. He was later an assistant coach for the Bonduel Bears junior varsity basketball team and a former coach for the seventh- and eighth-grade teams.
Fischer was a veterinarian in Shawano at the Shawano Veterinary Clinic for 56 years. As a veterinarian, he had the opportunity to care for President Ronald Reagan’s and President George Bush’s dogs, as well as many other exotic animals.
He was a member of the Shawano Masonic Inc. Fraternity and a Beja Shriner.
This year’s first fatal crash in Shawano County occurred in the city of Shawano on Feb. 1.
Cinda L. Engebretson, 61, of the town of Wescott, was southbound on Airport Road at Beauprey Road when she lost control and crossed the centerline, the Police Department said. She veered into the path of a tanker truck that was carrying road sand and was struck head-on.
She had worked for the Clintonville School District for 28 years.
Icy road conditions were blamed as a factor in that crash.


