The Shawano County Sheriff’s Department is pushing for overtime pay for correctional officers and dispatchers as efforts to fill its ranks continue to get more difficult, and the county’s public safety committee agrees something needs to be done.
The committee voted unanimously June 7 to move forward a resolution permitting overtime for the two non-union divisions of the sheriff’s department, which will first go to the executive committee on June 21 and then to the Shawano County Board of Supervisors one week later.
“This is something that we’ve worked with for two years now,” said Sheriff George Lenzner. “We’ve tried to figure out some way to get overtime for the jail and for dispatch centers.”
Lenzner said his department has been told previously to wait for things like the county policy handbook to be approved, and then the excuse that overtime would have to be open to all county departments if it was granted to the sheriff’s department, an excuse Lenzner finds ridiculous because most other county functions operate Monday through Friday, while his department is a 24-hour a day operation, seven days a week.
“I believe the highway department gets overtime for anything over their allotted hours, anything over 40,” Lenzner said. “We’re finally up to staff in the jail, basically, and we’re up to staff in dispatch, but other counties are fighting to get up to staff, and they keep putting more and more benefits out there. They all pay better than us, their overtime is better, and now the new thing is every county is paying a shift differential, including weekends. They’re giving employees an extra $1 an hour when you work a weekend or work nights.”
Troy Beyer, jail administrator, said the correctional officers currently work 84 hours in the two-week pay period, and that overtime does not kick in until after 86 hours are worked. Beyer is proposing that anything beyond scheduled shifts be paid overtime, which would be 1½ times the hourly pay.
“They’re here on nights, weekends, regardless of if they take a PTO (paid time off) day or not,” Beyer said. “If they have to stay over or come in on an off-day to work, they haven’t been getting time and a half.”
The scheduling differs in the dispatch center, according to Bill McGlynn, communications manager. The center falls under the federal labor laws that require overtime for any hours worked over 40.
McGlynn is also proposing the 1½ times the hourly pay for his dispatchers.
“We talked to HR (human resources) and the finance director about this near the beginning of the year,” McGlynn said. “In a year’s time frame, that would have calculated all hours worked outside of their normal scheduled hours to be around $10,000. That would fall within our overtime budget that we currently have.”
McGlynn said he wants to see overtime pay for any dispatcher who has to come in on a day off.
Lenzner noted that the sheriff’s department had asked for the same compensation when the county agreed to use American Rescue Plan Act funds to increase correctional officer pay by $3 an hour in 2021. That wasn’t granted, but the sheriff’s department is continuing to push for fair pay to avoid having staff go to other counties or to private sector jobs where the pay is higher.
Administrative coordinator James Davel suggested that overtime be included in the sheriff’s budget for next year, but he wasn’t ready to commit to a new policy on the matter.
“There’s a lot of pieces to this that have to be worked out,” Davel said. “I think putting it in the budget is the way to go. I just want to make sure that all of the requirements are understood, because when you start talking about overtime, this isn’t the organization that does overtime. Maintenance does overtime. Highway does a tremendous amount of overtime. I think it’s more than just one department, per se.”
McGlynn noted that the highway department gets paid overtime if they have to work longer than their 10-hour daily shift, and there’s more pay if they have to work on Sundays.
Lenzner said he’s tired of being told that overtime for the sheriff’s department would require offering overtime to all departments, considering other departments already have the privilege.
Davel pointed out there are differences between the highway department and the sheriff’s department.
“Highway generates their own money, so when they do that work, there’s a difference in how the money’s coming,” Davel said.
Lenzner dismissed Davel’s argument, questioning why law enforcement would be required to generate money for the county.
“Since we don’t generate money, our guys get punished for that, and it’s not right,” Lenzner said. “Other counties find a way to do that.”
The sheriff added that the pay issue is going to need to be worked out soon anyway, because the ARPA funds run out in 2024, and without a new solution, the $3 pay increase correctional officers received two years ago could disappear.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


