The Shawano School Board will soon be deciding if it wants to keep Kobussen Buses as its transportation company for the next few years or if it wants to chart a new road with Lamers Bus Lines.
Kobussen’s proposal submitted to the district offers the district a base rate of $234.58 per bus for the first run of the day, with additional runs or shuttles being $41.40. The proposal also provides a $1.40 cost per mile for miles over 60 miles per day per route.
Midday routes with Kobussen would cost the district $63.11 per bus per day, plus the $1.40 cost per mile if the routes go over 30 miles.
The proposal also is asking the district to pay $24.07 per hour for an attendant on the bus, with a minimum of 1½ hours. When it comes to bussing teams to events or classrooms on field trips, Kobussen is asking for $25.65 per hour and an additional $1.40 per mile with an $80 minimum charge and $80 for any cancellations.
The prices are expected to change annually based on the National Consumer Price Index, with adjustments being no less than 2%.
Lamers’ proposal asks for an annual base cost of $41,000 for up to 173 days of service, along with a surcharge of $1.95 to $2.20 per mile depending on the number of routes established. The base cost would increase to $43,077 in the 2024-25 school year and $45,240 in 2025-26, with the mile surcharges also increasing.
Summer school routes would be $237 per day plus $1.50 per mile, and after school late runs and midday routes would cost $69 per day per route plus $1.50 per mile.
For extracurriculars and athletics, Lamers is proposing $24 per hour per driver, with a minimum trip charge of $88 during non-peak times and $149 for peak times.
Lamers’ fee for bus attendants would be $22 per hour, with a 2-hour minimum charge.
Superintendent Kurt Krizan told the board at its April 17 meeting that Lamers was looking to be the bus vendor for the next seven years, while Kobussen is seeking a five-year term. Lamers is offering up to 20 routes, he said, while Kobussen is currently providing 17 routes to the district, plus two special education routes.
“Lamers is offering pricing for fuel into their bid, whereas we’ve always contracted separately with Kobussen,” Krizan said. “Right now, we’re at $43.64 per bus per day (for fuel).”
With the new contract, the district is also looking at returning to double routes, according to Krizan, where the elementary schools would start at one time and the middle and high schools at another time instead of having all grades ride the same bus and all of the schools starting and ending at similar times.
“For both of those proposals, if we went back to that, we would see a reduction in the number of routes,” Krizan said, noting the district pays about $320 per day per route. “We would be saving about six routes.”
The double-route system would require almost an hour difference between the start times of the elementary and secondary schools, Krizan said, with a recommendation that the higher grades start school at 7:30 a.m. and the lower grades starting at 8:20 or 8:30 a.m. The single-route system was established in 2018 after scientific research was presented showing that older students need more sleep in the mornings to perform better in school.
Krizan noted that some of the high school students are complaining about the loss of school time with a later schedule, especially those who must travel to athletic events or other activities before the school day is done.
“We really need to figure out what the impact’s going to be on our families and take a look at the options for us,” Krizan said.
Board member Mart Grams noted that having the older students in school early could mean the younger siblings are home alone if parents have to be at work. He also cited the research that a later start time is better for older student performance.
“Little kids handle very well that 7:30 or 8 o’clock (start time),” Grams said. “That research has been out there for decades, but schools ignore it because sports are more important than children.”
Krizan noted the timing of double routes would be dicey either way, because if the elementary students started school first, they would also end first and potentially be home alone after school because the middle and high school students are in school for another hour.
The district plans to survey parents on their preferences before bringing the proposals back to the board for a final vote.
Krizan said that Lamers currently offers wi-fi on its buses while Kobussen currently does not but is looking into it.
“I think we have two good proposals here,” Krizan said.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


