A Pulaski man will serve three years in prison for an accident that killed a man walking on the side of County Road S in Sobieski last December.
Judge Michael Judge on Sept. 20 also ordered five years of extended supervision and 250 hours of community service for Joseph Anderson, 36, saying he turned what could have been a tragic accident into a criminal offense.
Anderson was arrested a day after George Birr, 51, was found in the ditch on the morning of Dec. 22, 2015. Authorities believe Birr was hit between 8 and 10 the previous night.
Judge acknowledged Anderson might have been a “victim of circumstances,” because of the dark and rainy night that made it difficult to see Birr, who was dressed in dark clothing walking along the road.
“I don’t care. You had to stop,” Judge said.
Judge said other drivers told authorities they saw Birr walking at the side of the road or in the roadway, but they were able to swerve to avoid him.
“I believe that Mr. Anderson’s collision with Mr. Birr was an accident. He certainly did not intend to collide with Mr. Birr,” Judge said. “What was not an accident was Mr. Anderson leaving the scene. That was intentional.”
After plea negotiations in July, Anderson was found guilty of homicide by negligent operation of a vehicle, which carries a maximum penalty of five years confinement and five years supervision. Anderson, in jail since December, received credit for his 273 days served.
With the extent of damage to his vehicle — a broken headlight, windshield damage and a passenger-side mirror torn off —Judge said Anderson was required to “stop, own up to what he did, call 911. But he didn’t do that. He left the scene.”
Judge said he was unsure if alcohol factored into Anderson’s decision not to stop.
“Whether you were impaired that night, I don’t know,” Judge said.
Anderson told authorities in December he had one beer while helping a friend build a giant Jenga game. Then, driving home, he thought he hit a mailbox, a trash can or a deer.
“The responsible thing would’ve been to stop and see what I hit. I know this now,” Anderson said at his sentencing hearing. “But I never saw Mr. Birr.”
Anderson said he was incredibly sorry to Birr’s family and friends and was filled with remorse. He said he didn’t expect a pedestrian to be walking on the side of the road on a rainy night in December. He lost a brother in a tragic accident and said he wouldn’t want that loss to be felt by anyone.
He asked for leniency, saying he was needed to help his 16-year-old daughter and his mother.
Anderson’s attorney, Aaron Krzewinski, suggested two options for sentencing: 12 months in jail and three years extended supervision or 15 months in prison and three years extended supervision. He described Anderson as hardworking, always willing to help others.
“He’s not the type of person who would leave the scene knowing he hit an individual,” Krzewinski said.
Letters in support of Anderson characterized him as an excellent worker, a devoted father and a man with a good heart, Judge said.
His daughter, Alexis, testified that Anderson was “the best role model I’ve had,” and Anderson’s friend Chad Cherzenka told of his compassion and willingness to lend a hand.
“Don’t place him in prison where violent defenders are, because he’s not one,” Cherzenka said.
Assistant District Attorney Robert Mraz recommended 2 1/2 years imprisonment and five years of extended supervision, saying “everyone knows how to deal with accidents.”
Birr’s daughter, Holly Birr-Kleczka, said no consequence was “big enough ever to compare to the life of my father.”
“We’re the ones who need to pay the ultimate consequence of your actions, so please let something positive come from that,” she said.
Anderson will serve his 250 hours of community service as a volunteer with an emergency unit, hospital or rescue squad, a recommendation made by Birr’s sister, Edna Schuettpelz, who testified at the sentencing hearing. She said Anderson acted totally irresponsibly.
“I hope … that when you become 51 in 15 years that you can say you’ve matured, that you’ve become responsible and become a better human being,” she said.


