Skip to main content

State scours Mud Lake history

Handwritten records from 50 years ago could affect whether Shawano County can sell part of the Mud Lake Wildlife Area for redevelopment near Cecil. Officials from the state Department of Natural Resources say their agency has veto authority wherever the county used state funding to purchase land for the wildlife area starting in the 1960s. So state officials are reviewing records of grants issued to Shawano County long ago — some less than $100 — to determine exactly when and where money helped the county to assemble the Mud Lake property. Doug Haag, the DNR’s deputy director of facilities and lands, said that although record-keeping was not sophisticated years ago, the agency has found handwritten records of about 25 grants to Shawano County dating back to 1966. “It’s the best information we have,” Haag said. Mud Lake Wildlife Area is an estimated 320-acre conservation site owned by the county, located on the southern edge of Cecil. Village leaders are urging the county to sell about 15 acres bordering state Highway 117 so that the property can be developed with businesses. The village would like to annex the development site to bring in new commercial growth. County officials initially sounded open to the idea, but they also acknowledged that DNR approval might be needed because of past state funding associated with Mud Lake on the condition that the property remain a protected conservation site. County officials recently passed a policy requiring closer consideration of such long-term conditions whenever accepting state grants or other outside funding. Cecil Village President Jeff Nolan declined to comment on the Mud Lake issue, citing the uncertainty on whether there will be state intervention. “I just want to see what happens,” he said. Shawano County officials could not be reached for comment. Some conservation advocates have voiced concerns about the proposed sale of Mud Lake property, which is used for hunting and other public recreation purposes. Bob Bohardt, a Shawano County delegate to the Wisconsin Conservation Congress, said he is remaining neutral on the Cecil plan, but he is concerned about other protected sites being offered up for sale if the Mud Lake proposal goes through. “That’s how this stuff starts,” he said. “Where to do you draw the line?” To some, the source of funding used to purchase the wildlife area is not even relevant. John Hoeffs, chairman of the local delegation to the Conservation Congress, said the county should refuse to sell any part of the Mud Lake site, regardless of whether the DNR has veto authority. Hoeffs said the property is an important site for wildlife protection and conservation. “The county owns it, and I don’t think they should sell it,” he said. Haag said the DNR has asked Shawano County to provide information indicating when the county acquired different sections of the Mud Lake Wildlife Area, so that those purchases can be compared with when the state allocated grants to the county. State records indicate about 25 different allocations between 1966 and 1987, ranging from as little as $42 to more than $2,000. Haag would not speculate what would happen if no clear correlation could be established with the Mud Lake property. But if it appears state funds helped acquire the 15 acres being considered for sale, state officials would invoke their authority to decide whether the site should be sold or whether it should continue to be protected for public recreation purposes, he said. “The goal would be to try to make sure that the public remains whole as far as the recreational investments were made,” he said.