Attorneys battling over a federal raid on a cannabis crop planted by the Menominee Tribe of Indians differed Friday on whether the tribe can legally disregard Wisconsin’s state law banning such crops.
U.S. District Judge William Griesbach heard arguments in a civil lawsuit filed by the tribe after federal drug agents Oct. 23 raided and confiscated the crop, which had been growing on the tribe’s reservation north of Shawano.
Agents later said the crop included thousands of illegal marijuana plants, but Menominee officials insisted it was industrial hemp and they are seeking a judge’s ruling that the tribe is within its rights to grow hemp.
Hemp is a milder form of the cannabis plant and is used legally in many commercial products such as clothing, paper and detergents.
Under farm regulations, the federal government has permitted hemp crops in states where growing such crops is allowed under state law. Wisconsin, however, has not legalized hemp farming, and that has become a central issue in the Menominee tribe’s fight in U.S. District Court in Green Bay.
Lawyers for the tribe argue that the reservation should be regarded as its own state, partly because Wisconsin in the 1970s agreed that the Menominee tribal government could enforce its own criminal laws free from state jurisdiction.
“Wisconsin gave up its right to have its criminal laws apply on the reservation,” tribal attorney Timothy Purdon said in court Friday.
Attorneys for the federal government counter that only states can authorize hemp farming under federal law, and that extending the powers of state government to a native American tribe would go beyond anything that federal lawmakers intended.
“I don’t think Congress was trying to make it very complicated,” government attorney Kathryn Wyer said Friday.
Griesbach gave no indication how soon he would issue a ruling.
The judge questioned attorneys on both sides of the dispute frequently during the 90-minute hearing. He quizzed the tribe’s representatives on the statehood issue, and he asked the government’s lawyers to explain why drug agents chose to confiscate the Menominee crop rather than try a different approach to resolve the matter.
“It seems heavy-handed,” Griesbach said of the raid. “I’m just wondering.”
Tribal Chairwoman Joan Delabreau said after the hearing that she was pleased the tribe had its day in court. The federal drug raid was troubling to Menominee leaders, Delabreau said, adding that she felt confident the tribe’s lawyers had made a compelling case that the tribe’s rights were violated.
Referring to the government’s attorney, Delabreau said: “I was really shocked. I felt her arguments were relatively weak.”
According to tribal leaders, they had alerted federal officials last year when the tribe legalized hemp production and then planted a crop on tribal property along County Road M. Raised in partnership with the College of Menominee Nation, the crop was cited as an experiment to determine whether hemp production could create a new source of economic activity for the impoverished tribe.
Agents from the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration raided the site on the morning of Oct. 23 and confiscated what they later described as 30,000 marijuana plants, some up to 6 feet tall. A federal affidavit said consultants from Colorado were assisting in the operation on a 20-acre site that was protected by security guards. A sign posted at the scene declared it “a permitted and experimental industrial hemp field.”
Menominee tribal leaders objected to the law enforcement action and then filed their federal suit Nov. 18.
The question of whether the tribe’s crop was marijuana or hemp has not been an issue in the civil case.
Lawyers for the tribe have asked Griesbach to issue a summary judgment in their favor, while the government has argued that the matter should be thrown out.
Wyer said Friday that tribal officials have failed to make a credible case for a judge’s ruling because they are challenging the government’s rationale for raiding the cannabis crop rather than challenging the raid itself.
“It’s backwards, your honor,” Wyer said.
Purdon responded that the court does have authority to judge the current dispute. He pointed out that the federal government is disregarding marijuana sales in states where local drug laws have been relaxed, and yet the government, he said, sent armed agents to raid a hemp crop where an impoverished tribe was hoping to find a new source of revenue.
The disagreement between the tribe and government, Purdon said, is not merely hypothetical.
“This a real dispute,” he told the judge. “It does go to the perception of the tribe that they have been treated unfairly.”


