Skip to main content

Rare voter fraud case being prosecuted in Shawano County

The case of a Shawano man accused of voter fraud represents the only known instance of that alleged crime having occurred in Shawano County in at least 25 years. John D. Jeske, 42, is accused of voting twice in the April 5 election, once in the city of Shawano and once in the town of Herman, according to a criminal complaint. Jeske was released on a $500 signature bond after a court hearing last week and is due back in court Monday for an adjourned initial appearance. Pam Schmidt, who has been Shawano County clerk since October and has been with the office for 25 years, said there is only one other alleged voter fraud case she can recall, though it was never prosecuted. She said a case was referred to the district attorney’s office in 2009 involving a voter who allegedly cast a ballot in Belle Plaine and another ballot in Outagamie County. “Nothing ever happened with it,” she said. Wisconsin’s Voter ID law, heralded as a means of preventing fraud at the polling places, has been through numerous court challenges but was in place at the time of the April election. It apparently did not help prevent this alleged case of voter fraud, however. Schmidt said the alleged duplicate vote was not discovered until after election day, when the names and addresses of voters who had cast ballots were placed into a state database — something that would have been done regardless of the Voter ID law. Though voters were required to present a photo ID in the April 5 election, the address on the ID did not have to be verified if the voter was already registered and listed with an address in the poll book. Addresses are confirmed at the time of registration. According to Shawano city staff, Jeske registered to vote in the city of Shawano on election day, and a Shawano address was verified. Officials later discovered that Jeske had also signed in at a polling place in the town of Herman and was given a voting number there, according to the criminal complaint. Jeske denied having voted in the town of Herman, according to the complaint. Jeske could face a maximum 3 1/2 years in prison and a $10,000 fine if found guilty.