A judge last week refused to dismiss the case against two Gillett teenagers accused of squirting whiteboard cleaner in their teacher’s soda, despite the police chief’s decision to dump out the soda and recycle the bottle, thus eliminating the opportunity for lab testing.
In issuing his ruling Friday, Oconto County Circuit Court Judge Jay Conley said Chief Jess Keplinger was negligent but did not act in bad faith when discarding the bottle.
The soda bottle was the key piece of evidence in the case against Hailey Brock, 18, and Gavin Gilbertson, 17. The teens are charged with being party to the crime of placing foreign objects in edibles and second-degree recklessly endangering safety for allegedly putting a couple of squirts of whiteboard cleaner in the drink of teacher Ray Johnson on Oct. 20 at Gillett Secondary School.
Johnson complained that his throat and stomach burned after drinking the soda, and the school nurse called for an ambulance, suspecting Johnson had been poisoned.
Advice from crime lab
Keplinger said he consulted with someone at the Wisconsin Department of Justice crime laboratory in Wausau several days after the incident and was told there was no way to test for the cleaning chemical in the soda bottle. Keplinger testified that he poured the contents of the bottle in the sink in the department’s evidence room and placed the bottle in a recycling bin.
When questioned by Attorney Aaron Krzewinski, who represents Gilbertson, Keplinger acknowledged he did not consult with the district attorney or an independent crime lab for a second opinion before he discarded the bottle and its contents. He also could not name the individual with whom he consulted at the state lab.
Krzewinski asked for the charges to be dismissed, citing the destruction of the only piece of evidence in the case. He argued that Brock told authorities she sprayed the cleaner over the top of the bottle, not inside.
“In severe felonies that have intent, it’s absolutely imperative to determine where is that foreign substance, in or on the object, and how much of it’s in there,” Krzewinski said.
Kevin Musolf, who represents Brock, questioned why a fingerprint analysis was not completed on the bottle. Keplinger said he wasn’t concerned about fingerprinting because so many people had touched the bottle.
Keplinger said he determined what was sprayed in the Mountain Dew bottle after interviewing Brock and Gilbertson at the school on the day of the incident.
“Nobody here today could say what could have been in the bottle. That’s why it should have been preserved and tested,” Conley said. “Anything can be tested. You can test something and get no results.
“I think that was absurd advice that Chief Keplinger said he received from the crime lab.”
Conley denied the motion to dismiss based on case law that indicates the defense attorneys either needed to prove the state failed to preserve evidence that apparently favored Gilbertson and Brock, or the state acted in bad faith by destroying evidence that potentially favored Gilbertson and Brock.
In denying the motion, Conley said the opposite occurred when the bottle was discarded.
The state’s case against Gilbertson and Brock would have been stronger if the soda had been available for testing, Conley noted.
School behavior referral
Conley also ruled that disciplinary action involving Brock the day before the incident could be presented at her trial but not at Gilbertson’s.
Johnson testified that he referred Brock to Principal Steve Linssen during a study hall Oct. 19 after she failed to follow his repeated instructions to move her feet and legs off a counter where snacks are sold.
Linssen testified that he met with Brock on Oct. 20. Linssen said Brock admitted she was out of line and was giving Johnson a hard time, just joking around.
Conley said Brock’s behavior referral can be presented to the jury as a means to determine her motive and intent to do harm, though he acknowledged Linssen’s testimony could provide evidence it was a prank instead.
Conley also ruled the behavior referral can’t be used in Gilbertson’s trial, because there was no evidence he knew about it.
Trial dates set
Brock’s trial is scheduled Aug. 2-3, and Gilbertson’s is Sept. 27-28.
If convicted of recklessly endangering safety, the students face maximum penalties of 10 years in prison and a fine of $25,000. The charge of placing foreign objects in edibles carries a maximum penalty of 3 1/2 years in prison and a fine of $10,000.


