Skip to main content

Suring chooses option to rectify arsenic problem

Following the advice of the its engineering consultants, the Suring Village Board on Aug. 9 chose the most economical solution to maintain safe levels of arsenic in Well No. 2. The board unanimously agreed to a move forward with an ion exchange option, aggressively cleaning or replacing the resin in the ion exchange vessels, in an effort to keep the well operational. Steve Lepak, Terry Stebor and Gayle Lindenberg, engineers from Robert E. Lee & Associates Inc., attended the board meeting to answer questions and reassure the board of their recommendation for Well No. 2. Lepak said the system has been fouled through the years and suggested that using cleaned or new resin will allow the system to run properly. He said replacing resin every five years or so will cost $20,000-$30,000, which is more economical than the other options available. Other options included sand media filtration, at the cost of $760,000; iron oxidation pretreatment, at a cost of $1.4 million; and a green sand pressure filter,at a cost of $900,000. A new system would take time to implement and comes at a higher price, he said, and Well No. 2 needs to be up and running. It has been offline since February 2016. Les Steffeck, Suring’s director of public works, remained skeptical the ion exchange option was the best solution. “When it works, it works good, but it is short lived,” he said. But Lindenberg reaffirmed the recommendation made by Lepak. Lindenberg said she would like to give the ion exchange system another try, due to the adjustments and modifications made to the system in the last few years. In April, Suring initiated a pilot program proposed by Robert E. Lee and Associates and Envirogens, the manufacturer of the treatment system. Initial tests results showed the pilot program would be successful in removing iron. Then it was determined the filters would not be reusable, making the program less economical, so the pilot test was terminated. At a special meeting of the Suring Village Board on July 19, Lindenberg defended the system, saying the firm is confident that by aggressively cleaning or replacing the resin in the ion exchange vessels, the present system will work. In July the board voted to table the decision until its August meeting. Trustee Angie Whiting did not attend the board meeting due to work responsibilities but left a memo with her decision. The start-up cost is $20,000-$30,000, which should maintain the system for five to 10 years, until the resin needs to be cleaned or replaced. Suring requested Robert E. Lee Engineering & Associates Inc. share the cost, a suggestion the consultants said the firm will consider. Well No. 2 was initially shut down in October 2009 because the arsenic levels exceeded Environmental Protection Agency standards. In May 2010, about $1.2 million was spent on improvements intended to solve the problem and provide Suring with a secondary source of water. The project was fraught with problems throughout the years, mostly caused by iron in the water clogging up the system that removes arsenic. The village has used various methods to get the system to work and keep the well running. Well No. 2 is located south of Suring at 8794 State Highway 32, near the intersection of Highway 32 and County Road M/Z. A new well station was built to house the filtration equipment designed to filter out arsenic and iron. Suring also has two wells across the river from the village and is required to have Well No. 2 in case the river crossing is compromised.