Skip to main content

Retzlaff bond reduction request denied

An attempt to reduce the cash bond for Ann Retzlaff, facing a myriad of felony and misdemeanor charges that first began in 2021, was shot down Oct. 4 by Marathon County Circuit Court Judge Mark Moran. Defense attorney Michael Hughes attempted to paint his client as “indigent” after already paying several other bonds from previous arrests stemming from not showing up to court in person and losing her campground west of Gresham, Annie’s Campground in another case in 2022. Hughes recommended that all but about $10,000 be slashed from $57,000 in bonds set for the cases so Retzlaff could afford to pay and get out of jail to aid in her defense. “We all know that Ms. Retzlaff has already submitted $16,000 into the system for bonds into all of her matters, which is a sizeable amount of money — especially for Ms. Retzlaff, who is indigent, which is why she’s receiving legal representation due to a court appointment,” Hughes said. “She has to post, in the four cases before us, another $57,000, which is far outside of her ability to post.” He noted that the purpose of the bond was not supposed to be to keep Retzlaff locked up indefinitely but to compel her to appear in court. Hughes claimed that Retzlaff has $5,000 to $10,000 at her disposal that she could post for bond. “She can post that money and continue to be represented and go through all these cases while still enjoying her liberty interests,” Hughes said. “I understand and appreciate that Ms. Retzlaff did have a warrant out for her arrest for quite some time. I think the court can address that by imposing certain non-monetary conditions to her release.” Hughes continued by pointing out that proceedings “went sideways” when she did not appear in court in person but tried to request appearing by Zoom. Hughes claimed that Retzlaff did not feel safe coming to Shawano County and that she feared for her life, along with “retaliation for blowing the whistle on various issues.” Moran was not buying it, however. He pointed out how much he and the court had bent over backwards to accommodate Retzlaff, including reducing a $25,000 cash bond last year to $15,000 and then granting a request for Retzlaff to take her kids on a holiday trip outside the state last December. That resulted in her being a wanted fugitive for the first half of 2023, when she missed another court hearing in January. “I have tried to be more than fair with Ms. Retzlaff,” Moran said. “At least twice she has been picked up on these warrants, and I simply have no assurances whatsoever … that she’s going to return to court. In fact, every indication from the past shows she would not avail herself of appearing in court.” Shawano-Menominee County District Attorney Greg Parker argued the bond should stand as is because of her pattern of getting out of jail and then failing on more than one occasion to appear in court. He also claimed there’s no case for Retzlaff’s life being in danger that his office or law enforcement has been able to determine. “Each time she has got out, she has involved herself with more violations of law,” Parker said. “This is her fourth case, and she has four failures to appear in 2021. She has shown that she will flee the jurisdiction of the court and left the state. Also, she has not turned herself in. It was not until the sheriff’s department had posted a recent jail picture of her that we found out she was hiding out in a place in Oconto County.” Retzlaff has been charged in Shawano County with felony counts of fleeing and eluding officers and two counts of second-degree recklessly endangering safety, as well as a misdemeanor count of resisting or obstructing an officer from a police pursuit in May 2021. She also faces misdemeanor charges through Menominee County for resisting and failing to stop. Retzlaff’s first failure to appear was in October 2021 as she cited illness, but when she failed to appear again a few weeks later, a bench warrant was issued, and she was arrested soon after. Retzlaff paid the bonds but missed court again in November 2021, which prompted the court to issue body-only warrants. Retzlaff was recaptured in April 2022 in a restaurant in the Town of Wittenberg and a third case with additional charges of bail jumping and disorderly conduct was established. She paid her $15,000 bond in August 2022, and in December asked Moran for permission to leave the state for the family holiday vacation, which Moran granted. However, at the next court hearing Jan. 12, Retzlaff was again a no-show in the courtroom, and Moran issued bench warrants that allowed for her to be arrested nationwide if located. She was arrested in Oconto County on Aug. 23 after the photo posted by the Shawano County Sheriff’s Department yielded a tip that she was in the Town of Lena. She’s facing two more felony bail-jumping charges after it was discovered she left Wisconsin for Michigan prior to her request for the family vacation. Hughes claimed the latest bail jumping charges filed in late 2022 should be dismissed during a preliminary hearing also held Oct. 4, claiming the evidence from the criminal complaint amounted to little more than hearsay. “Too much hearsay with no corroboration,” Hughes said. “It’s not a plausible story without some level of reliability and discovery from law enforcement. We’ve tried to determine if that exists, and there doesn’t appear to be, certainly not on the record.” Parker noted that the purpose of a preliminary hearing is not to determine the credibility of witnesses but to determine if there’s enough evidence to bind someone over for trial. Moran agreed, noting that hearsay is permitted in a preliminary hearing but not for the trial itself. He ruled that Retzlaff should be bound over for trial based on testimony claiming Retzlaff left the state in early December and traveled to Holland, Michigan. “Inferences are what’s important for preliminary hearings,” Moran said. “If there are competing inferences, I have to look at whether there are reasonable inferences that are plausible.” Retzlaff is facing five counts of criminal slander of title and two felony bail jumping charges in Sauk County after allegedly filing false liens against representatives with Bank First and the new owner of the former Annie’s Campground, now known as On the Rocks Family Kampground. lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com