The Wittenberg-Birnamwood School Board approved revisions to its 2022-23 budget on June 26, which included $500,000 for Fund 46, the school’s capital projects budget.
Originally, noted Superintendent Garrett Rogowski, the district had budgeted $87,000 for the fund, which is available in case there is an unforeseen capital expense that needs immediate attention, such as roof damage from a severe storm or a boiler going out.
Board member Trevor Szutkowski questioned why it was necessary to make such a move with the surplus of funds. He felt it would be better to use the surplus on other things like boosting teacher pay.
“When you have that much of a surplus, there are probably more things we could have done during the year,” Szutkowski said. “I know we’re doing a good job with our expense management, but it seems strange to put this into Fund 46 and then to lose a teacher that we’re not paying enough, and then we have to spend $46,000 on capital improvements.”
Fund 46 money is not allowed to be transferred to another school fund once it is placed there, according to the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.
Rogowski pointed out that having a reserving a surplus for capital work is “a really good practice” so that, if something bad happens that requires a lot of money to fix, the district is not left scrambling to figure out how to pay for it on the spot.
“I think it’s wise for us to do it, because it helps to keep our taxes down,” Rogowski said.
He added that teachers’ wages are recurring costs, and even though the district might have a surplus this year, there’s no guarantee it will have that surplus in future years that could go toward teacher wages.
“We’re competitive, but we’re not at the top,” Rogowski said of Witt-Birn’s staff wages. “If you want to be the highest paying school district in the area, you’d have to almost have a recurring referendum.”
Szutkowski asked Rogowski if other schools were putting similar amounts as Witt-Birn into Fund 46. Rogowski said he didn’t regularly check other school districts’ budgets, so he did not have an answer.
“If it’s repeated over and over and over (adding to Fund 46), then maybe our budgeting needs to be better,” Szutkowski said. “It seems like a lot.”
Rogowski noted that the district could also use up that fund with larger capital projects than it would normally budget for instead of waiting for tragedy to strike.
“To roof this building, which will eventually come up, we don’t have a budget for that (normally),” Rogowski said. “You could spend half a million.”
Outgoing Wittenberg-Birnamwood High School principal Stuart Russ pointed out that saving for a rainy day was better than having to explain why things are broken later.
“I’ve been in community meetings where there’s $25 million in deferred maintenance costs and people are up in arms because, ‘How could you not plan for this? How could you not have stuff set aside?’” Russ said. “That’s a tough sell for the community, as well.”
Szutkowski said he understood the administrators’ points, but felt it was important to explain that to the community so people could understand why the money is just sitting in a savings account.
Rogowski pointed out that Witt-Birn isn’t constantly allocating huge amounts of money for its school buildings, so having the funds available in case improvements are identified.
“At the end of the day, what do we have from a facilities standpoint?” Rogowski said. “It’s not like we’re pouring money into our buildings to the point where we have all of these amenities that other schools do have. I’d ask, what are the extravagant things we have in the community?”
Szutkowski stressed that the district is experiencing the same difficulties as other school districts when it comes to teachers — losing the good ones to other school districts that pay higher salaries.
“I’m not worried about us spending money, unless we lose our best kindergarten teacher,” Szutkowski said. “That’s where the frustration is.”
Rogowski said the debate between staff pay and keeping the buildings in good working order is a constant one for all school districts, but he questions if the district is going to be able to pay its teachers the highest wages in the area without having to sacrifice something else.
Szutkowski said it’s impossible to fully compare the local school district with others because of an area’s unique needs, but he feels it’s best to have the reputation where teachers are happy and not having to worry about personal or financial security.
“What we can do is hire good teachers and be known for that,” Szutkowski said. “That’s what’s important. That’s just where I’m coming from.”
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com
Budget revisions include capital fund boost


