Birnamwood Elementary-Middle School’s library also serves as the community’s library, but there is a concern that the library serves as a bypass for the front office when it’s open to the public during school hours.
The Wittenberg-Birnamwood School Board voted unanimously June 26 to have the community access the library outside of school hours so there would not be an intermingling of adults and children during the school day. Representatives from the school district are expected to meet with the Shawano County Library Board on July 10 to present the proposal.
The board learned that an option was presented to the Shawano County Library Board earlier this month that would put a wall up between the community section and the area where children would get their books. The library board rejected that option, according to Superintendent Garrett Rogowski.
“I think this is a big deal,” he said. “You don’t want to lose the community library. We’ve had some parent concerns that patrons of the Birnamwood Public Library, which is a joint school and public library, that the library is open most school days at 11ish and that it produces a risk for our students.”
Patrons are able to walk in the library and not always be monitored due to the large size and L-shape of the facility, Rogowski said.
“They have easy access into the school hallway by going in the south door,” Rogowski said. “We probably have 150-200 students a day that go in and out of the library for checking out books or for accelerated reader (programs) and all kinds of things.”
Locking access from the school is out, according to Rogowski, as it’s not wise to expect young children to have electronic access cards to enter the library, so that was where the idea of the wall came in, something that could be pulled away during non-school hours so that children who come in with their parents could access the children’s books.
“We thought we could put a circulation desk near the wall and then move the adult literature to that side of the library, where they come in from the side road, and at 3:30, when the kids leave, if they wanted to access the children’s section, they could open a door or the partition wall and come in,” Rogowski said.
Omni Glass from Oshkosh presented the district with a $4,600 quote for the glass door, according to Rogowski. The additional circulation desk was expected to cost $1,000.
Rogowski said the library board rejected the idea because of the agreement with other municipalities and that it didn’t “want to open a can of worms” by helping to pay for a barrier between the school and the public side of the library.
“The next best option — which I think is the best option — is to open (the public library) at 3:30 and then you would be able to run the library as normal with the library staff,” Rogowski said.
He added the library board wasn’t thrilled about the second option, either, and it was planning to discuss what options it was willing to take at its July 10 meeting. Rogowski noted the agreement for the library puts any maintenance at the cost of the school district, but the district doesn’t see constructing a wall as maintenance.
“We were looking at this partition as maintenance,” Rogowski said. “It was almost a renovation, so that’s why I thought for them to chip in was fair.”
Not allowing the public library access to the facility is not an option, in the superintendent’s view, because it would negatively impact the community to not have a library in the village and be forced to go to either the Wittenberg or Mattoon libraries for literary and other needs. Rogowski said he wanted the board’s approval before approaching the library system with the recommendation of separate hours for the public library vs. the school library.
School board member Trevor Szutkowski said he had no problem backing Rogowski’s recommendation.
“We have to protect students at all costs,” Szutkowski said. “If they are not willing to put any money in, and we put the money to do that, they could leave a year from now. They’re looking for an excuse.”
Board member Rich Olson agreed a determined stance was necessary to resolve the situation.
“I don’t get why they wouldn’t want to put student safety first,” Olson said. “We either separate the two areas, or we have separate hours for when the public can access.”
When the suggestion came up to present both options to the library board for comparison, board member Dan Stewart was flatly against giving a choice.
“I don’t think we need to keep that proposal active,” Stewart said. “We offered it once, and they said no. I don’t believe they need to think about it more. The only other option is to have the separate hours. It’s the best answer.”
Rogowski noted the Birnamwood school has a paraprofessional that runs the library for the school, and he noted that almost all of the resources are under the school’s authority. He said that, other than the parent concerns about school safety, school library and public library employees have an excellent working relationship.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


