Skip to main content

Gillett school officials concerned about AI impact

Gillett School District officials gave the school board a primer on artificial intelligence June 15 to alert them how AI is going to revolutionize teaching and learning, for better or for worse. “It isn’t something we can avoid,” interim Superintendent Wayne Johnson told the board. “It’s here and there’s nothing we can do about it, so we can either use it and capitalize on it or we can run and hide, and I don’t think that’s really an option.” Johnson said “it’s absolutely mind-boggling” how quickly tasks can be done using AI, and done well for the most part. “The thing that we really, as a school district, need to be prepared for is how this is going to impact teaching and learning and what it means,” he said. “It’s something we have to be prepared for really quick, because it’s here, it’s not going away, and it’s evolving by the day.” Theoretically a student could go on an artificial intelligence site, like ChatGPT or Google Bard, and finish their homework in three seconds, Johnson said, but although AI can churn out a factual essay within seconds, it cannot form opinions. “If you ask (AI) to write a theme about a personal matter or something that just happened in the news, it doesn’t work,” Johnson said. “If you’re asking about dinosaurs, this is going to give you a 500-word theme that’s going to blow your socks off, because there’s all sorts of knowledge out there about dinosaurs.” Teachers will need to craft assignments that require the student to provide that personal input, he said. Chad Steinmetz, instructional technology coach, said that inability to form opinions is key. “It’ll list facts for days, but it’ll not actually tell you that the student likes something, if it can relate to something,” Steinmetz said. “This is a robot in some room, somewhere. That personal communication or that personal reflection in that story is just not there.” ChatGPT launched in November 2022 and Google Bard on March 2023, and students tested its abilities almost immediately, he said. “We had academic dishonesty within the first month, and I had to block it for kids. It was absolutely in this building,” Steinmetz said. The district “got lucky” with that first attempt at using AI to cheat, he said. “They were middle schoolers, and the piece that they produced was well above their writing level, so it stuck out like a sore thumb. We were able to take care of it right away.” Steinmetz gave the board a demonstration of Google Bard’s abilities, asking it to describe the Statue of Liberty for a blind person and getting several paragraphs of information within seconds. Then he asked the same question, adding, “please write that at a third grade level.” In less than five seconds, the AI replied, “The Statue of Liberty is a big statue of a woman holding a torch. It stands on an island in New York Harbor. She’s a symbol of freedom and hope for people all over the world.” On the plus side, Steinmetz said AI can be a time-saving tool. He prompted it to develop a quiz featuring “four questions with four multiple choice answers on the subject of Wisconsin” and craft an email summarizing the minutes of a recent school board meeting. “It’s unbelievable how smart these things are,” he said. “It’s very, very cool.” Johnson said he experimented with having the AI draft letter of recommendation for a teacher, giving it only that the person had been teaching a specific subject for nine years. “I got a six-paragraph letter of recommendation that would blow your socks off, with that minimal amount of information,” Johnson said. Teachers will need to be aware that some students will try to utilize AI rather than learn how to do the work themselves. “You as a teacher realize that some kids are going to do this, so how do you write an assignment that you know the student actually did and actually read the story?” he said. As the presentation wrapped up, elementary principal Curt Angeli said: “How long before SkyNet becomes self-aware?” His reference to the villainous artificial intelligence in the Terminator films drew nervous chuckles all around.