Skip to main content

Nelson gets 30 more years in fraud case

A Missouri man serving life sentences for murdering two Shawano County brothers was sentenced April 25 to an additional 30 years for defrauding them in a cattle transaction. According to court documents: Nick and Justin Diemel, of Bonduel and Pulaski, respectively, had the misfortune of contracting with Garland J. Nelson, 28, of Braymer, Missouri, to feed and pasture about 316 feeder calves until they could be sold. Beginning in December 2018, Diemel’s Livestock, LLC, agreed to pay Nelson a daily fee per calf. Nelson pastured the calves at the farm of an Amish man, John Gingerich, for a fee but Nelson was responsible for their care. Nelson never paid Gingerich the fee and never provided enough feed for the calves. Gingerich would call Nelson from a neighbor’s phone to ask for more cattle feed but Nelson ignored the calls. When Nelson provided feed, he didn’t remove the plastic netting from the feed bales. The underfed cattle ate the netting, which, along with neglect, contributed to their deaths. Before many of the calves were buried on his farm, Gingerich cut them open and found large amounts of plastic in each calf’s stomach. By early March 2019, Nelson’s uncle came to Gingerich’s farm and counted 90-100 dead calves and 25-30 sick ones. He couldn’t get an accurate count of all the dead calves as they were stacked on top of each other. Despite the many dead calves, Nelson, through his mother’s company, J4S, continued to bill Diemel’s Livestock for all 316 head. In April 2019, Nelson sold 118 head at auction. Nelson kept cattle for other owners, and as Diemel calves died, he would cover their loss with the cattle from other owners so he could continue to overbill the Diemels. In late April 2019, Nelson moved the remaining Diemel calves to his mother’s farm, according to witness accounts, where they continued to die. A month later, Nick Diemel received the call from David Foster learning that Nelson had killed many of the calves owned in partnership with Foster. Nick Diemel also found that Nelson had a federal fraud conviction. Nick Diemel pressed Nelson for either payment or the return of his cattle. Instead, Nelson sent Diemel’s Livestock a $215,936.50 check written on a bank account that had only a 21-cent balance. Nelson had torn the check so it couldn’t be presented for payment. Nelson, through J4S, continued to overbill Diemel’s Livestock for feeding and yarding the cattle that had died. On July 19, 2019, J4S billed Diemel’s for 279 head of cattle for April through June. On July 20, 2019, the Diemel brothers went to Nelson’s farm to collect on the bad check. The next day, Jack Diemel filed a missing persons report with Caldwell County authorities after his sons failed to board their return flight home. Based on their investigation, authorities believed that Nick and Justin Diemel never left the J4S property after they arrived and were intentionally killed by Nelson. Nelson told local authorities that he found two bodies he believed were Nick and Justin Diemel dead, each inside of a 55-gallon barrel in a pole barn located on the J4S farm. The bodies were then moved in a skid loader bucket to a pasture and burnt. Then the bodies were placed in a manure pile near a metal barn and Nelson said he crushed the barrels using the skid loader. Nelson added that he returned to the pole barn and used a shovel to remove blood from the floor where it is believed the Diemels were killed. He was sentenced last year in Johnson County, Missouri, to two life sentences for the murders of Nick Diemel, 35, and Justin Diemel, 24. Nelson was charged with in federal court with wire fraud and a business fraud offense. After pleading guilty in October, he faced 30 years to life in prison and a restitution order. Nelson’s attorney contested the restitution contending that any claims were satisfied by a $2 million settlement paid to the Diemels’ next of kin, including Nick’s four children. Federal prosecutors disagreed, arguing that the $2 million didn’t fully compensate Nick and Justin Diemel’s families for the lifetime loss of their earnings, the pain and suffering inflicted from the murders and desecration of the bodies plus, the economic loss of the fraud involving the dead cattle. The government also argued for the maximum sentence to be served consecutive to the previously imposed murder sentences. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Kathleen Mahoney and Nick Heberle contended that severe punishment is warranted due to the “horrific nature” of the offenses, and that Nelson’s criminal history spans his entire adult life and includes passing bad checks, defrauding the USDA loan program and a federal cattle fraud conviction. District Judge Beth Phillips ordered Nelson imposed a 30-year sentence, to be served consecutive to previously imposed sentences and pay restitution of $260,925.