The issue of abortion took center stage April 17 when state Sen. Robert Cowles came to Shawano for a listening session.
Much of the almost two hours Cowles was at Shawano City Hall was spent talking about where the state should stand on the issue. Kris Labby, a retired public health nurse, noted that she leans left politically but is anti-abortion, but she said the issue would be a tough one to legislate.
With the U.S. Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade, which permitted abortions nationwide, the issue has been sent back to the states and whatever laws they had at the time. For Wisconsin, it goes back to an 1849 law where abortion was banned, and so the Wisconsin Legislature has to figure out whether to continue with that law or move forward with a new one.
“I don’t envy the legislature about making decisions about this, because it’s a medical and health care decision,” Labby said.
Labby referenced the recent decision by Florida to implement a ban on abortion after a woman has been pregnant for six weeks. She said that is, in essence, a ban on all abortions because of the time it takes for someone to find out they’re pregnant.
“Gestational age is counted from the time of a woman’s last period,” Labby said. “If she had her period, she’s not pregnant then, but if a fertilized egg happens, that’s approximately two weeks later. It would be about two weeks (after that) where she would have her next period, except it doesn’t come, so she’s technically four weeks pregnant, even though the fertilized egg is two weeks there.”
By the time women realize they might be pregnant, whether through a home test or being able to schedule a doctor visit, the six-week period might have lapsed by then, Labby said.
Cowles said he is in favor of adjusting the 1849 law to allow exceptions for rape, incest or if the mother’s health is in jeopardy. He noted the existing law is not synchronous with surrounding states and that some Wisconsin women, the ones who can afford it, are traveling to other states for the procedure.
“We’ve got a whole pipeline of people going down to Illinois,” Cowles said. “It’s a dicey, complicated issue.”
Labby said that, of about 6,000 abortions annually in Wisconsin, about 1.5% are for rape, and even fewer are conducted because of incest.
“Most abortions are not done due to rape or incest,” Labby said. “Somewhere around 98% are done for other reasons — financial reasons, wasn’t ready for a baby.”
Cowles noted something needs to be done at the state level because of a lawsuit challenging the 1849 law going to Wisconsin Supreme Court, and if it’s overturned, the question of abortions being legal becomes even murkier.
“This is likely to get overturned,” said Cowles, noting that Janet Protasiewicz’s recent election to the court has it leaning left. “and then we’re right back to wide open (abortions), and I’m pretty sure the people in my district want something slightly less.”
Cowles also spoke with one woman about the issue of nursing homes in Wisconsin and being able to relocate a loved one closer to the Shawano area, as well as speaking with City Administrator Eddie Sheppard about the city’s early success in removing all lead lines from the city’s water system.
lpulaski@newmedia-wi.com


