Skip to main content

Legend Lake property owners file suit

Members of the Legend Lake Property Owners Association want a federal judge to reverse two decisions by the Bureau of Indian Affairs that take 40 Legend Lake properties into tribal trust for the Menominee Indian Tribe. The complaint by the association filed April 11 in federal court alleges that Guy F. Keshena acquired title to 40 parcels, totaling 21.35 acres, in 2017 within the Legend Lake development. Keshena acquired the properties as an individual but pursuant to tribal authorization. Eight years before Keshena’s property purchase, the association enacted a set of covenants. The suit focuses on the covenants that restrict the sale of any property that would remove it from the tax rolls of Menominee County. Keshena knew about the covenants when he purchased the property. The tribe also knew about the covenants but still petitioned the BIA to take the 40 properties into tribal trust. In 2018, the BIA’s Midwest Regional Director authorized the transfer of the properties into tribal trust status. The association appealed that decision, which was upheld last March by the Interior Board of Indian Appeals. In its decision, the interior board concluded the trust acquisition criteria do not recognize the association’s covenants, the covenants are preempted by federal law, and the covenants cannot render the regional director’s decision “null and void.” Importantly, the Menominee Restoration Act made it mandatory to approve the tribe’s petition to take the properties into trust status. In its federal suit, the association contends that the interior board didn’t have authority to decide if federal law preempted the covenants. Also, the interior board erred in not properly applying the restoration act which recognizes that property taken into trust is subject to liens, outstanding taxes, mortgages and “any other obligations.” The interior board failed to explain why the covenants didn’t constitute “any other obligations” as stated in the restoration act, and the interior board also didn’t address why the entirety of the covenants were preempted and not just those that clashed with the restoration act, according to the lawsuit. The association sued Keshena and the tribe in Menominee County Circuit Court also on the issue of whether the covenants are preempted by the restoration act. The case remains pending on the association’s appeal after Circuit Court Judge Katherine Sloma’s decision to dismiss it. That suit doesn’t involve the BIA officials or the interior board decision. Regarding the federal suit, the association contends that its members’ property values will be reduced if the interior board decision stands and the organization will become “a paper tiger” because the owners would be left without the protections of the covenants. The suit seeks a court order vacating or staying the interior board’s decision until the case is resolved. A call to Frank W. Kowalkowsk, attorney for the association, wasn’t immediately returned. The Legend Lake area was initially developed in the late 1960s. The association was created in 1972 and membership is mandatory for all property owners. The association’s purpose has been the efficient management, maintenance and operation of properties within the Legend Lake area, according to its website.